We ate there after a con recently – it seemed like unpretentious food and it had a lot of good reviews – and were astounded at how bad the food was. The hamburgers were tasteless mush (I ordered medium rare and got medium well), the salad was “the worse I’ve ever tasted” and “had some bits still frozen.” One guy said his meatballs were good, but they only served three not-very-large meatballs, which for $17 seems not worth it. No one was happy, and on the drive back to Portland we had to make extended use of the travelers rest areas.
I felt embarrassed, since I was the one who looked up “where to eat in Puyallup, Washington” and recommended we eat there (although a couple of locals told me it was good). In all, our table probably spent $150 on that meal, and it was virtually all a waste.