Category Archives: Same-Sex Marriage

Elizabeth Marquardt responds to me

Elizabeth Marquardt, of the Family Scholars Blog, responds to two posts of mine, here and here. I’ll respond in turn to at least one of these sometime later this week..

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 2 Comments

Since when has heterosexual intercourse been central to the definition of marriage? Since sometime after 2000, according to the Institute for American Values

A few weeks ago on MarraigeMovement.org – a blog owned by The Institute for American Values – David Blankenhorn wrote: What about the idea that marriage, by bringing together into enduring sexual union the male and female of the species, … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 22 Comments

An overly-long response to Elizabeth Marquardt regarding gay marriage

(You know, any reader who isn’t interested in the same-sex marriage debate is probably going to be driven off my blog this week. Sorry, folks.) (Please note, as you read this post, that I am not accusing Elizabeth of being … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 28 Comments

In the eyes of the goverment our family never existed

In the comments to an earlier post, an Alas reader asks, in essence, what is the purpose of marriage? In my opinion, the purpose of marriage is to allow people to form new families, and to have our new families … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 8 Comments

Same-Sex Marriage is needed to protect children

Although opponents of equal rights for gays claim to be concerned with the best environment for raising children, their policy goals in practice only harm children. There is no legitimate evidence that children are harmed by being raised in a … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 5 Comments

What social science says about gay parents

Over on the MarriageDebate blog, Eve writes: WHAT DO THE STUDIES SAY ABOUT SAME-SEX PARENTING? Hey, look, you can get a nice review of literature here. However, the link Eve provides is to an anti-gay-equality site, which – surprise, surprise … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 53 Comments

Same-sex marriage: the stalemated sumos

Here’s the best passage from an otherwise forgettable Jonah Goldberg column on same-sex marriage: Until now, the White House has largely taken a do-nothing policy toward gay marriage and a moderately pro-gay stance – by conservative standards – in other … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 1 Comment

How not to engage an opponant's arguments

Over on the Family Scholars Blog, David Blankenhorn “can’t let go of Katha Pollitt’s argument” for same-sex marriage. Like many same-sex marriage adovcates, Pollitt argues that we don’t require straights to be able to reproduce in order to have legal … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 20 Comments

Why they really oppose same-sex marriage

It’s not a huge surprise, but a Pew Research Center poll on gay marriage shows that opponants of same-sex marriage are motivated far more by religion than by a desire to protect children. (In contrast, the conservative intelligentsia tend to … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 1 Comment

My kind of conservatives

In the comments to one of Amp’s posts there seems to be a bit of polite back and forth between some of the liberal and libertarian Alas readers. I have to say, I’ll probably disagree with libertarians to the bitter … Continue reading

Posted in Same-Sex Marriage | 26 Comments