Hat tip to Ben Lehman!
Recent Comments
Cartoon: Unions Have Always Done The Impossible!
Cartoon: It's All About Caring, Fatsos
Cartoon: The Measure of Intelligence
Cartoon: Hey did you hear? Biden is old!
- Link Love | Grumpy Rumblings (of the formerly untenured) { […] Cartoon: Hey did you hear? Biden is old! […] }
- Ampersand on Apr 5, 2024 at 12:09 pm
- Avvaaa on Apr 4, 2024 at 10:27 pm
- Ampersand on Apr 4, 2024 at 6:09 pm
- Duncan on Apr 4, 2024 at 12:49 pm
Cartoon: The Celestial Politics of Trans Bans
Cartoon: "Sex Is Real" Is A Euphemism
Cartoon: Let's Outlaw Being Homeless! That'll Work!
Cartoon: Appealing to Trump Voters by Getting Tough on Immigration!
- Older »
Most Recent Open Thread
The most recent open thread can always be found at the top of this page. When older posts have closed comments, please respond to them on the most recent open thread.Alas, a Blogroll
- Lawyers Guns and Money
A Man With Room to Talk
2 hours ago - The Incidental Economist
Qualitative Brief: Better Understanding VA Urgent Care Delivery
5 hours ago - Election Law Blog
“Can Proportional Representation Create Better Governance?”
5 hours ago - Family Inequality
- Long Story; Short Pier
Bookkeeping
Yesterday
- Lawyers Guns and Money
Barry’s BlueSky
- Untitled May 6, 2024What I find curious about this thread is that the image he's critiquing is much, much more interesting than any of the images he brings up as examples of good images. The "Lois and Clark" images in particular are blandness personified. [contains quote post or other embedded content]
- Untitled May 6, 2024#PoliCartoon [contains quote post or other embedded content]
- Untitled May 6, 2024Israel apologists: "Student protestors should be arrested! Rule of law!" Also Israel apologists: "If rule of law goes against Israel, we'll take revenge on the prosecutors and their families!" https://zeteo.com/p/exclusive-you-have-been-warned-republican
- Untitled May 5, 2024Flash forward to 2094, when people who are ten now will be like "the internet was different back then! We were all friendlier... there were hardly ever trolls... Now it's all gone to shit."
- Untitled May 4, 2024This is either incredible stupidity or incredible dishonesty from the cops, and I honestly can't tell which.
- Untitled May 6, 2024
Alas, A Subscription Service
Archives
Categories
I dunno, its hard to tell from exate dates from this graph, but it looks like participation trophies both started and ended the great depression, while declining greatly in mentions in books searchable be google for the duration of WW2. Thereby not leaving too much of a correlation to work with.
Why they were most popular in the 1950’s is a mystery though, but it looks like you have a better argument for participation trophies causing the anshluss between Germany and Austria or put a man on the moon then won WW2.
I find it telling, somehow, that the 1980s were a drought decade for (mention of) participation trophies. Greed Is Good!
It’s interesting as well, though, because I was a teenager in the 1980s and I could swear that I remember hearing tons of “participation trophies are ruining America!” nonsense even back then. I guess it just didn’t make it into the published works.
Are you sure that wasn’t just Ed Anger?
I did a quick Google Books search, and it looks like the ones in the 50s are trophies awarded to frats/sororities for their participation in sports or Greek Week. e.g.”He had tears in his eyes because his fraternity had won the all- university participation trophy on the basis of the track meet.” “Alpha Beta, for the second consecutive year, received the WRA Participation Trophy for the best participation in all sports.” “The following week they moved on to victory and won the Greek Week All-Participation trophy.” So not actually an award given to an individual for participating but to a group for getting high levels of participation. And now the word “participation” looks weird…
Heh. I think of Ed Anger often lately. Were his column being published today, I doubt anyone would interpret it as satire.
But actually, I think it may just have been Chappaqua. It was very much the sort of town where no one could take any real satisfaction in winning anything unless they felt assured that it meant someone else would be losing big.
I never thought about it in those terms but it explains so much. It still is that sort of town.
And, yeah, good old Ed was decades ahead of his time. If he were alive and active today, he’d be making a fortune in right wing media.