Just a quick one, dashed off in response to some of this week’s news. As folks here know, I usually do cartoons intended to be about lasting issues, and that’s going to continue to be the case.
But I thought I’d experiment with adding some relatively quick-and-messy “news of the day” cartoons to the mix. Let me know what you think!
TRANSCRIPT OF CARTOON
PANEL 1
CAPTION: JULY
An angry, balding man in a suit and tie points accusingly at a woman, who looks taken aback.
MAN: Progressives have to support centrist Dems like Josh Turek and Haley Stevens! Vote blue no matter who!
PANEL 2
CAPTION: NOVEMBER
Josh Turek and Haley Stevens, both depicted as snakes with human heads, smile at each other.
TUREK: I voted Republican this year!
STEVENS: Same!



The problem I have with this argument in the various forms I’ve seen it presented is…okay, then what? Vote for Hinton? Don’t vote? Vetting better in the primaries might help if it can be done and there is a decent candidate to support, but that isn’t something that can be done now (which is probably why they’re coming out with these statements now rather than in the primaries, at a guess).
That being said, snakes should be offended at the comparison to Stevens and Turek. Also, is Stevens a king snake? A coral snake?
She’s a cemophora coccinea. There was no reason for me to make her a cemophora coccinea, beyond “oh, that looks fun to draw!”
As for what then… Vote for who you want to vote for, but be more skeptical of moderates in future primaries. I really want any moderate democrat in a primary to be asked and asked again for detailed positions on trans rights, immigrant rights, and Gaza. There’s no perfect guarantee, but it’s the best we can do.
Heh. I would love to be skeptical of moderates if I could find any. We’ve got the right wing, the far right wing, and the overt fascists in the US and I don’t see anywhere else that’s all that much better right now. Agree about the primaries anyway.
I really hate that slogan. That slogan is what they were pitching at the last democrat caucus I went to. It did not help build enthusiasm for candidates or the platform. No more caucusing for me.
“Vote Blue No Matter Who” is interesting… I don’t know when or where it originated, but I have the impression that it really picked up steam after a lot of DSA supporters decided to endorse Jill Stein over Kamala Harris running up to 2024. I think the intention more than anything was that while you can (and should) have robust primaries, even if your preferred candidate loses, it was more important to hold your nose and get Democrats in.
I think there was this interesting switch in the 2026 midterm where instead of centrist Democrats trying to coax the DSA to vote for centrist Dems, the DSA was using it to try to coax centrist Democrats to vote for DSA, and people like Stevens are the flip side of things like the “Uncommitted” movement, “Abandon Harris”, or all the DSA people that endorsed and said they voted Stein. I think everyone is about to learn the wrong lesson from this midterm because while all signs point to a GOP blowout in 2028, once Trump is a cycle removed from the political scene, I don’t know if there’s going to be a frightening enough figure on the right to maintain the connection between the two sides of the Democrat Party which seem to absolutely loathe each other.
“Vote Blue No Matter Who” seems to have been created by an ordinary twitter user back in 2015. It became really big during the 2016 primaries, often as a rebuke to the Bernie or Bust movement.
” all signs point to a GOP blowout in 2028″
The copium is strong in this one
….You don’t think the GOP is going to get blown out in 2028?
Sorry, maybe this is an ESL thing. I don’t think there’s anything the GOP could possibly do to reorganize after this, unless a Democrat at the state level shits the bed so hard they break the frame, I think the GOP is absolutely cooked for 2028.
I think people usually say “[team] blowout” to indicate that [team] wins. See this NPR headline, for example.
We were here once before, remember, back in 2006. The Democrats campaigned on Holding Bush Responsible For The Iraq War and won a majority in both houses — and then after they took office they announced that impeachment was “off the table” (very much Pelosi’s pet phrase) and worked with Bush to fund his “surge”… And then they ran on continued outrage at Bush (which only still existed because they refused to stop him!) and took the White House as well — and then refused to so much as appoint a committee to investigate Bush, and had another “surge” of their own. That was a war that was eventually admitted to have been based on lies, which (by the time Bush left office) killed a million people and was estimated to have cost the US $2 trillion-with-a-t. (In point of fact, you can date Trump’s 21-century Presidential ambitions from Obama’s first term, because it is very clear that Trump only ran because he saw that you could lie a lot, kill a lot of people, waste a lot of money, and face no consequences whatsoever. If Obama had prosecuted Bush, Trump would not have run in 2016.)
That’s not going to happen again — but not because they’re going to hold Trump responsible; it’s not going to happen again because they have already betrayed us. Jeffries announced about a month ago that no matter what the election results were, the Democrats would not try to impeach Trump, and a few weeks ago held a meeting with Republicans which turned out to have been about how to implement more of Trump’s agenda. We’ve been sold out preemptively, this time, and the change of majority party is pretty certainly not going to make a difference except to shift some of the blame for all the actively awful stuff going on from Republicans to Democrats.
I continue to vote — but I will not vote for Democrats any more, just as I never voted for Republicans. Genocide is the ultimate political crime, the thing we hung Nazis for at Nuremberg, and after Biden’s last 15 months in office, the party cannot be considered trustworthy, even tentatively, until and unless they expel everybody who was involved and announce that they will hold those responsible for the illegal funding of Israel’s genocide (I remind you that a law passed under Clinton made it illegal to fund countries which were committing genocide, so even ignoring everything else, and there’s a heck of a lot to ignore there like the ever-increased-by-Biden federal funding for ICE and the military and corrupt local police, Biden and crew should be imprisoned for that). That includes the Clintons, who also took a big chunk of Israeli money and were vocal supporters of genocide in exchange. And since the Democratic Party has been the Clinton Protection Agency ever since the Gennifer Flowers scandal came to light, sacrificing anything at all to protect those two greasy grifters at all costs, I don’t expect the party to have the integrity to put them on trial, even belatedly.
(You could write a good dark comedy about the way the Democrats spent so much time and energy getting publicly angry about foreign influence from Russia for 4 years and then nominated and put into office a guy who took millions and millions from AIPAC, explicitly the public front for foreign influence from Israel, and he broke the law to assist their government — unquestionably to the detriment of the US, since that’s what caused the Democrats to lose to Trump again in 2024. The hypocrisy would be astonishing if they hadn’t already pulled a 180 on Iraq and demonstrated for 8 years under Obama that ultimately their platform is basically “screw our voters, we’re doing what the rich want”. After that, no matter how brazen it is, it’s no longer a surprise.)
Got’cher. Did not mean that.
I actually kind of view this as positive in that it signals that maybe the Democrats are moving away from performative political bullshit. You’d need 67 senators to convict, and there was never any chance of that… The Democrats would have had to win all but two of the senate seats up for grabs and pray Fetterman didn’t buck. I mean, really… How much money are you willing to spend putting on a show trial with no chance of conviction for a president with a short clock? There’s more important shit to do, and maybe the Democrats can leverage some sanity into the process.
What, exactly, have they done that you think they need to move away from? They let Reagan off the hook for Iran/Contra, never confronted — or investigated — GWB over Iraq or drone bombing or anything else, we now have leaks showing that Biden deliberately kept the Department of Justice from prosecuting Trump for January 6 because “it would set an unfortunate precedent” if Presidents were held responsible for breaking the law… they’ve been the most pathetic excuse for an opposition party imaginable, and opposition party which only “opposes” in rhetoric and then only when safely in a minority.
Trump is going to veto anything positive the Democrats pass, and by your own arguments about numbers they won’t be able to override that without Republican support, which isn’t going to happen, because they don’t have 60 votes in the Senate. The only thing they can do without Trump’s cooperation — which, again, isn’t happening — is show trials and investigations. And those are actually a positive thing, as the Republicans have shown, because it gets your base to understand you would do something if you had the numbers; it gets people to understand what the issues are and where you stand on them. Democrats have spent the last 36 years showing that even when they have the numbers, they won’t even try to do anything because… well, because of a bunch of implausible excuses, a partywide preference for “dignity” (in the form of never showing any enthusiasm over anything except war no matter how important) over accomplishments, and a fairly blatant preference for right-leaning fiscal and foreign policy. Obama wasted a genuine electoral mandate with majorities in both houses of Congress doing basically nothing of value — the ACA was a waste of time, being a giveaway to the private insurance industry which was unsustainable in the face of Republican disagreement, and the Democrats used it as an excuse to avoid ending the Iraq war before the 2011 deadline set by GWB or breaking up the Too Big To Fail banks (or restoring the Glass-Steagall trading regulations, which would have prevented most of the 2008 meltdown had not Clinton, acting on advice from Libertarian Alan Greenspan, pressured Congress to repeal them… you can draw a line straight from that repeal to the derivatives trading which caused the crash). Over 92% of all Americans, including over 90% of Republicans, wanted the financial sector punished for the meltdown; had Obama done that, rather than making excuses and bailing out the bad actors who caused the crisis and chasing bipartisanship which was never going to happen (the Republicans openly announced on the night of Obama’s inauguration that they were going to refuse to cooperate with anything the Democrats proposed, and followed through — even giving them the benefit of the doubt, after a week any sincere and intelligent person wanting to accomplish anything would stop trying to compromise with them) he would have had the political capital to do anything at all afterwards. Instead, he implemented everything but the name of GWB’s proposed authoritarian “Total Information Awareness” domestic spy program, expanded the drone bombing program despite the CIA’s official conclusion (they were the ones who invented the program) that it was counterproductive, made double-tap drone bombing (look it up — in a sane world, it would have gotten him a war crimes trial immediately) official policy as well as declaring that any adult male killed in by a bomb was a terrorist to keep the “innocent civilians killed by the drone bombing” numbers down, proposed austerity to pay for all of that, but increased funding for ICE and built them the cages that Democrats later raged Trump was putting kids in, and, of course, refused to have the DoJ prosecute GWB, possibly because most of the big names in the Democratic Party like Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden had been enthusiastic supporters of the Iraq war and making an issue of it would have killed their careers. (How I wish their careers had been killed! It would have saved us from both of Trump’s wins!)
“I think people usually say “[team] blowout” to indicate that [team] wins.”
Yep. And for the record, Corso, English is my first language.
Well… At least the second performative show trial doomed to fail, if not even the first. I don’t know if this was a serious question and you were probing where I’m at, or if this is a deliberately obtuse pretention that the Democrats aren’t the epitome of doing it for the cameras. Like when AOC dressed up in white and cried at a fence, or when the Democrat lawmakers donned kente cloths for George Floyd, depite no evidence that he had any connection to Ghana. Performative support that very rarely transitioned into legislative action. Spending money to larp as activists. Buying your support with empty platitudes. It even sounds like you agree with me, down below, you just don’t want to actually agree with me:
But they’ll put on a hell of a show while doing it! Right? The one disagreement I have is with this:
That’s obviously not true. The statutory debt ceiling will have to be increased sometime in early 2027. If the Democrats were serious about leveraging something out of the administration, they’ll have opportunities. If a SCOTUS judge decides to retire in the next little while (Thomas is 78), they can do to whoever Trump taps what the Republicans did to Merrick Garland. And even if that weren’t true… Part of the reason Trump’s been able to run so roughshod over the last two years is that he won the presidency and the Republicans won the house and senate… Elections have consequences. Even if all you can do is slow the awful by not letting new awful through, that’s a win.
Et tu le fais drôlement bien!
I think Jeffries was stupid to accept the premise of Joe Scarborough’s question, which was how Jeffries intended to keep House Democrats focused on economic issues rather than retaliation against Trump. The resulting soundbite (“Americans don’t want us to get even, they want us to get things done on their behalf”) was predictably picked up on by left wing ragebaiters (to be clear, ragebaiters are found among all political groups, not just lefties) and went viral.
Jeffries answer was dishonest and accepted a false binary, so it’s fair he’s gotten roasted for it. For one thing, some of his promises it’s really unlikely that he can deliver on until Trump is replaced.
In the same interview, replying to a question about Robert Garcia’s “Lawyer Up” warning to the Trump administration and allies, Jeffries also said:
So taking the interview as a whole, Jeffries wasn’t coming out against all consequences.
I personally think that – unless things change – it makes a lot more sense for Democrats to focus on investigations into all sorts of corruption surrounding the Trump administration, and for consequences when they have the power, but not to go for impeaching Trump unless impeachment becomes more viable.
I also think it makes sense to propose and push a lot of economic bills, and force Republicans in the Senate to squash them. That’s performative, but it’s not only performative. Not only could that help in 2018, it also means that if the Dems win the Senate and White House, they’ll have some bills ready to go fast.
—
The idea that politicians shouldn’t be performative is, I’m sorry Cosco, ridiculous. All politicians, if they’re any good at what they’re doing, do some performative things. They are public figures trying to build support for their policies, and it’s absolutely right they do that. I guess in a perfect nerd world designed by me, they’d all skip all that and just release position papers which the public would eagerly study and discuss, that’s not the world we live in.
Anne on a Mouse, I know a lot of people who have crucial medical coverage because of the ACA’s enormous expansion of Medicaid (which got less coverage, but is actually an enormous part of the ACA). Saying it did nothing is going way too far; those people matter, and getting them medical coverage isn’t nothing. It wasn’t perfect, but it did a lot of good.
(Admittedly, it did the most good in Dem-controlled states, where Republicans couldn’t block the Medicaid expansion. But that’s really not the fault of Democrats.)
I’m of the stance that the Democrats should pass a bill with universal healthcare, universal basic income, universal housing, cuts to the military and a wealth tax, and call it something ridiculous like “Donald Trump’s Big Tremendous Huge Amazing Law to Make America Great Again and to Repeal and Replace Obamacare With Something Terrific, and Rename the Indian Ocean the Trump Ocean,” to see if he signs it based on the name without reading it.
Mind you, I don’t think the Democrats will do this. But it seems more productive than passing a law that they know Trump will veto, and much better than passing laws Republicans like.
Like the poet, or the dog, not the store :p
Obviously. But there are levels to that. There’s difference in size and scope between doing a land acknowledgement before giving a speech and spending millions of dollars trying a person you know that you can’t convict, and cannot run again for office. If you want me to condemn the equally ridiculous performativity on the right: Eagerly.
I actually think this is to some extent an Americanism. Your politics for some reason are almost quasi-entertainment. I guess it’s possible that your mileage may vary depending on where you are, and there’s bound to be more colorful places (I’m thinking of New Zealand, where every now and again their parliament gets Haka-bombed), but the politics in places I’ve lived has always been so much more…. boring. Which is good, actually.
@Corso: A haka is a deeply meaningful and culturally profound expression of indigenous identity and resistance. It is not “performative”.
@beth: I think this is the main hope, that Trump gets bored easily and is lazy, and has little patience for even scanning legislation letting alone absorbing a detailed analysis of it. So he might just lack motivation to rigorously veto every piece of a large slate of Democratic legislation. He’d still veto most of it, but the Trump White House is chaotic, and is likely to get more chaotic during the next two years, so there’s a decent chance at least some positive legislation could slip past the veto guard.
If it’s not performative, what did it accomplish?
Why are complaining against the “Vote Blue no Matter Who” concept? It’s objectively very useful to progressives, who have an easier time winning Democratic primaries than any other election. El-Sayed won thanks to moderate voters who did, in fact, Vote Blue no Matter Who, and rejected Stevens’ wrecker behavior.
The assertion of the mana and tikanga of the tangata whenua of Aotearoa.
Beth, I actually think it’s possible to get Trump to sign on to a health care bill. Not guaranteed, at all, because Trump is extremely mercurial. But I don’t think Trump believes in much other than his own ego. For the last 15-ish years, being a hard-core Republican is the thing that’s benefited his ego most; but if crossing the aisle to support major legislation serves his ego, I think it’s possible he’d do it.
Corso (sorry for getting your name wrong, btw!) wrote:
Earlier, Corso also wrote:
So are you claiming that AOC – who wasn’t even a member of Congress at the time – spent millions of taxpayer dollars to attend that protest?
Many right-wingers will point at a single act within a large lefty protest movement – like AOC attending a protest at the fence around a migrant detention facility – and saying “what did this one act accomplish,” as if that’s how mass movements work. But the whole point of mass movements is that thousands or millions of individual acts add up, not that each individual act has an independent measurable effect.
The protest AOC attended was part of the movement against Trump’s family-separation policy, and the movement had significant successes, although not “ended family separation forever” level success. The movement and public pressure certainly led to Trump signing his June 20, 2018 executive order directing officials to avoid separating families. (The protest AOC was at was four days after that – but of course had been planned since before the 20th, and not ending pressure and attention instantly was obviously the right move).
And although AOC isn’t a dictator and can’t pass legislation unilaterally, since entering Congress she’s co-sponsored bills related to this issue, like the 2021 Families Belong Together Act.
So your objection here seems meritless. AOC participated in a protest movement that had, for a time, a significant effect, and she followed up once she was in Congress, yet you choose it as your major example of performative nonsense.
(I have no idea what you have against people wearing white on 100 degree days. Is this like hating Obama’s tan suit?)
—
Kente originally comes from Ghana, but in the US it’s been a symbol of Black solidarity since the civil rights movement. James Clyburn, who organized sit-ins in South Carolina during the 1960s, was one of the congresspeople there wearing kente, and has said that he and other black legislators suggested that the Dem leadership should wear kente stoles – do you think you know better than him about when wearing kente is appropriate?
—
From what I can tell, a haka is literally a performance; it’s a genre of ceremonial dance, performed at both solemn occasions like funerals, and lighter events like sports. In the legislature, its use is mostly pre-approved, but there have been a couple of non-pre-approved events that made the news.
The one that made the most news was a 2024 protest to the Treaty Principles Bill; the dance was performed by three members of the legislature. This was part of a wider protest movement against the bill, which was later voted down by a huge margin. You can take this two ways:
1) The protest movement was in fact very successful. If this is true, then I think the members of the legislature performing a haku, causing the scheduled vote to be suspended, has to be seen as an significant event in a protest movement that accomplished its goal.
2) The bill never had a chance of passing, and the right-wingers who introduced the bill wasted an incredible amount of time and money for performative bullshit. (Or that’s what they did if we apply Corso’s standards).
—
There are some circumstances in which a impeachment can actually be politically meaningful, even if there’s no chance of a removal of the President. The obvious example is Bill Clinton; he was impeached in the House but acquitted of both charges in the Senate. You can call this a failed impeachment, in that it ultimately led to acquittal, but it was also enormously damaging to Clinton’s legislative agenda, and a very big disadvantage for Al Gore in the next election cycle. Very few people who understand US politics would say that Clinton’s impeachment didn’t substantially benefit Republicans.
No, that would obviously be closer to the tamer end of the performativity scale. The reason it’s one of the go-tos that come up when I think of performativity, is also the reason I mentioned what she wore: The slightly zoomed out pictures that didn’t exactly scream “authenticity”. She didn’t show up to a protest and was so moved by all the suffering people she saw. She showed up for a photo shoot and threw herself crying at a fence that didn’t have anyone on the other side of it.
I think we approach this from very different views. My impression is that you view protest movements as a whole and judge their effectiveness by the success of the movement as a whole, where I’m more likely to judge the individual protests within the movement on their individual merits. And this obviously transcends this discrete topic, we had variations of the same argument when it came to the separation of the BLM riots from the BLM protests. I think the riots did damage to the protest as a whole, and I think that if they were more universally condemned it may have mitigated some of the damage done at later stages. Your mileage may vary on that, we don’t have to rehash it, but we obviously have different views on the constitution of a protest body.
Depends what you mean by appropriate, I suppose. I didn’t say it was inappropriate, I said that it was an example of stupid, performative bullshit. “Performative support that very rarely transitioned into legislative action. Spending money to larp as activists.” Did the house pass a bill afterwards that I was unaware of?
As to the idea that it could be inappropriate… I’ve never really ascribed to the idea that cultural appropriation is actually a problem. But I also don’t really understand why this wouldn’t be a problem for someone who did. It’s not like James Clyburn has Ghanian roots either. Is there culture your costume if someone black says it’s OK? What are the rules here?
Not really, but also not 1. If ACT had floated the bill knowing it was doomed to fail, then absolutely. But I think that ACT didn’t forsee how unpopular their legislation would be with the Maori. Frankly, I don’t think that a lot of the legislators that passed it in the first reading did either. Frankly, I don’t think it was as bad as the Maori treated it, but they really didn’t like the lack of consultation. It’s not performative if you at least meant to actually do something. By the time the second reading had come around, 40,000 protestors were marching.
And again… This is where we differ. You’ll see the haka as part of the larger protest. I don’t. I absolutely think the 40,000 protestors changed the minds of the MPs that changed their votes between first and second readings. I don’t think the haka changed a damn thing, and I think it pissed people in the room off – The same MPs who voted the act down also voted to suspend the haka-dancing MPs for three weeks without pay.
How’d Trump’s work out for you? You think it’ll be much different a third time?
Before I reply to this, can you clarify what “didn’t have anyone on the other side of it” means?
Remember the Alamo, right? All no respect, fuck off with this dishonest, bad faith framing. “A fence?” What fence are you referring to, Corso? What happened there?
Why are you talking about Ghana? Which lawmakers invoked that country? You are not an American, so I’ll ignore rather than excuse the ignorance. Kente, which belongs to no single country*, is widely worn in the US, and in this case is intimately connected with the Congressional Black Caucus who were hosting the event you’re referring to and who handed out said garments. This was in aid of congressional Democrats’ promoting the common sense reform package called the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act of 2021, passed twice without GOP support, and failing in the senate due to radical rightwing resistance to federal guidance, oversight, and moderation of the then current and continuing prevalent model of violent, systemically racist local law enforcement currently imposed, or maybe we should say waged (as in war) upon us Americans. Said bill was very sanguine, indeed, only strengthening federal civil rights oversight, imposing a uniform standard of policing requiring transparency in records, reinforcing a basic definition of bias, and enabling local judicial officers to pursue misconduct charges on a uniform basis.
*and is globally recognized as a symbol of greater West African pride and the African diaspora as a whole. Catch me outside for reactionary rightwingers wringing their hands about any kind of colonialism here. Clean your own house.
” If ACT had floated the bill knowing it was doomed to fail, then absolutely.”
ACT’s two right wing coalition partners had stated they would vote against the bill, let alone parties outside government. It was absolutely performative. ACT knew exactly how much Maori would despise the bill – they didn’t consult because the consultation would have been “hell no”. Maori are not a monolith, but there is 0 chance that any consultation would have resulted in any form of endorsement.
It’s interesting that Corso claims that he agrees the right can be performative and that’s just as bad as when the left do it, and he just -happens- to be specifically talking about the left at this particular occasion (and the last one, and the next one) but whenever a specific case of right wing performativity is brought before him he always claims it’s not performative.
It’s lazy, strong arming, and doesn’t encourage candidates to actually listen to their consituents and respond to their needs. You are not automatically entitled to my vote because you’re blue. In practice it’s been very rare that I’ve voted for independents or greens, and I’ve never voted Republican in my life. But don’t demand my vote if you’re not gonna listen to me or respond to what I need in a candidate.
I can only assume that Corso means that if AOC had been sincere in her sentiments, she would have scaled the fence, physically defeated the multiple armed guards on the other side of the fence (who are visible in some of the photos of the protest), and protested a few feet from the tents for the maybe sixty seconds she’d have before the troops would have shot her.
I’m kidding. What Corso meant (I’m guessing) is that he believes that AOC was protesting at a site containing nothing but a fence and an empty parking lot. That’s what a lot of right-wingers believe (because the most mockable photo, if you believe humans don’t have feelings, was taken at an angle that caught an empty area in the background – other photos give a better idea of what the site is like), but it’s objectively false.
Also, he believes that this was a prearranged photo event. But she wasn’t famous yet; she didn’t know the photographer, hadn’t arranged for him to be there, and the photos weren’t even posted until a year later, when the election was long over. (Source.) Also, apparently left-wing women can’t look nice and have sincere feelings at the same time.
Edited to add: Turns out the organizers of the protest asked people to come wearing white.
“Former Massachusetts congressman Barney Frank once said, ‘I only voted once for someone who believes in 100 percent of what I believe. And that’s when I voted for myself—the first time.'” Al Franken, Al Franken, Giant of the Senate (2017)
Sure, if you oppose literally everything a candidate stands for, don’t vote for that candidate. But IF that candidate is a Democrat, and IF a Republican will win if the Democrat loses, and IF you oppose the Republican more than you oppose the Democrat, then I would conclude that you do NOT oppose everything the Democrat stands for.
In my case, the biggest thing I want from a (legislative) candidate is the vote for the appropriate leader of the chamber. (For example, in Congress that’s the Speaker of the House). Pretty much nothing else that candidate will do will be as consequential. I may like Republican Ray’s adament and principled work promoting environmental causes, say, but if Ray gets elected and then votes to make a Republican the Speaker of the House, that Speaker will likely ensure that no environmental laws get passed and existing envrionmental laws get weakened. Ray’s other pudative merits are thereby rendered irrelevant–basically just window-dressing.
In short, EVERY Democratic legislator offers me something I value–specifically, the opportunity to displace a Republican legislator, and thereby to eliminate a vote for a Republican leader of the legislative chamber. Thus, pretty much EVERY Democratic legislative candidate gets my vote. (Admittedly, if you live in a jurisdiction where you sometimes face multiple Democrats competing against each other in a general election, then you would face a more complicated decision analsyis.)
Yes, this philosophy results in voting for the “lesser of evils.” But that’s pretty much always true. The only election in which you agree with a candidate on everything is the election in which you vote for yourself–the first time. Every other election involves picking from among candidates who do not agree with you entirely. That’s democracy.
The trouble I see with “Vote Blue No Matter Who” is that the party machine / establishment / whatever abandons it when someone they dislike wins a primary. We saw that several times in the past year, notably with Mamdani, theatrically with El-Sayed. It’s been entertaining to poke Dem apologists with it, because they openly admit that they only mean it for candidates they like. We also saw this in 2008, when a good many Hillary Clinton supporters voted for McCain rather than Obama because it was Her Turn and the Kenyan Usurper had deprived of what was rightfully Hers. On the other side, while quite a few Dems didn’t vote in 2024, we lefties mostly held our noses and voted for Harris. So Corso’s memory is woefully short.
Just a few days ago, somebody in comments on Facebook denounced Noam Chomsky for ordering his enslaved minions to vote for Jill Stein instead of Democrats. This was delusional at best, because Chomsky has always taken flack for doing the exact opposite, saying that it’s important to vote strategically, for candidates who’ll do the least harm, and I believe he said he voted for Obama both times.
A note on “performative” – Corso keeps using this word, it does not mean what he seems to think it means, though by now the meaning is mostly lost. It was a term from philosophy, notably John Austin. It refers to language that performs an action, like “I now pronounce you man and wife” — making the statement makes the action. It kind of bled into less exact meanings until Judith Butler misused it in Gender Trouble — she later admitted that she hadn’t understood it, but by then the damage was done. I believe that a wave of college students heard it on campus, thought it sounded cool, and spread it like a radioactive virus. There are perfectly good words that convey the same meaning, such as “theatrical,” or “histrionic” if you want to be fancy. But now that’s what “performative” means.
It’s like “deconstruct” – it annoys the hell out of me when whiny former evangelicals say that they’re “deconstructing” their former faith. But word lost its meaning was lost even longer ago. In this case the whiny former evangelicals are so pretentious about it, though, and they haven’t really deconstructed anything, they’re still carrying their upbringings around like the Old Man of the Sea. Ah well. Thank you for attending my Ted Talk.
You’re missing my point.
Fuck the lesser of two evils. We need to demand better. And that is why I hate “vote blue no matter who”. If the Democrats always get people who will vote for them because the Republicans are even worse, what hope is there for change towards the better in the Democrats?
“vote blue no matter who” is a failure of imagination. When the Democrats have been moving towards the right so much that there is no functional left in the US, I refuse to give them my uncritical support.
In practice will I be “voting blue no matter who”? Yes, unfortunately, because we haven’t yet found a way out of this dysfunctional two-party system. But I’ll be damned if I’ll sign on to that slogan. And I’ll support those, Democrat or other, who put pressure on the Democrats to move towards ideas I support.
The Democrats have moved noticeably to the left since the 90s.
The same hope the Evangelical/Bircher/Fascist right had to move the Republican Party to the right. Since we live in a system that won’t support more than 2 parties, the only choice is to change one of the two parties from the inside. That’s been going on forever.
And so… I vote for the best, most progressive candidate in the primaries and then I vote for the least fascist candidate in the general. For example, Tina Kotek is NOT a good governor and I didn’t vote for her in the primary. However, Christine Drazan is a fascist nightmare who would’ve done what she could to ban abortion and defund Medicaid and so I voted for Kotek in the general. Sure, Kotek is the lesser of two evils but Drazan would’ve been catastrophic for the state and for women and queer people, especially.