Recent Comments
Cartoon: Unions Have Always Done The Impossible!
Cartoon: It's All About Caring, Fatsos
Cartoon: The Measure of Intelligence
Cartoon: Hey did you hear? Biden is old!
- Link Love | Grumpy Rumblings (of the formerly untenured) { […] Cartoon: Hey did you hear? Biden is old! […] }
- Ampersand on Apr 5, 2024 at 12:09 pm
- Avvaaa on Apr 4, 2024 at 10:27 pm
- Ampersand on Apr 4, 2024 at 6:09 pm
- Duncan on Apr 4, 2024 at 12:49 pm
Cartoon: The Celestial Politics of Trans Bans
Cartoon: "Sex Is Real" Is A Euphemism
Cartoon: Let's Outlaw Being Homeless! That'll Work!
Cartoon: Appealing to Trump Voters by Getting Tough on Immigration!
- Older »
Most Recent Open Thread
The most recent open thread can always be found at the top of this page. When older posts have closed comments, please respond to them on the most recent open thread.Alas, a Blogroll
- Lawyers Guns and Money
Mercedes Desperation
5 hours ago - The Incidental Economist
Effects of VHA’s Referral Coordination Initiative on Referral Patterns and Waiting Times
7 hours ago - Election Law Blog
- Asking The Wrong Questions
Ripleys
3 days ago - Family Inequality
Why I endorse the Sociologists for Palestine resolution
2 weeks ago
- Lawyers Guns and Money
Barry’s BlueSky
- Untitled May 2, 2024I love that Caterpillar boots were among the returned items, and in this photo an Amazon worker took, you can clearly see the "CAT" logo near the cat. Cat climbed into Amazon return box, found alive 630 miles away wapo.st/3JJ3vqT
- Untitled May 1, 2024A new cartoon for May Day! This has been an incredible year for unions in the USA - may next year be even better. Unions Have Always Done The Impossible! #PoliCartoon #Union #LaborDay2024 #MayDay2024 #May1st #UBI #LivingWage
- Untitled April 30, 2024People on reddit are fighting about a cartoon I did about why the US health care system sucks and I am enjoying this too too much. https://www.reddit.com/r/comics/comments/1ch0l0r/why_us_health_care_is_such_a_terrible_system/?sort=old
- Untitled April 30, 2024I just posted a new cartoon! It's patreon supporters only for now, but in a week or so I'll make it public. :-) https://www.patreon.com/posts/deus-ex-machina-103359912?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=postshare_creator&utm_content=join_link
- Untitled April 30, 2024Nothing against Brian, who of course needs and should make a living. But I'm increasingly frustrated by the Substackization of blogging/news writing. To read Brian's work I have to subscribe, which at the lowest price level is $75 a year. [contains quote post or other embedded content]
- Untitled April 30, 2024Cartoonists and illustrators: Watch out for this scam (it's been going around for a while, but I only heard about it recently). Person emails you wanting to commission a bunch of illustrations to go with a presentation. Pretty high offer. At the end, they mention they want to pay you by check.
- Untitled May 2, 2024
Alas, A Subscription Service
Archives
Categories
Ruben Bolling On Race And IQ
This entry posted in Race, racism and related issues. Bookmark the permalink.
Reason # 1,268 on why “Tom the Dancing Bug” is awesome.
Speaking of “Tom,” it seems that Washington Post is thinking of canceling the strip in January. If you read the newspaper, I hope you take the time to write to the editors on why this is a bad idea.
Ha! Excellent.
/grin.
but where can we see more of this comic? is it not online somewhere?
fathima,
Try http://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug
Exactly.
Oh, and Charles, I loved the truthtelling of this strip so much, I went to the gocomics space and — the Dec. 22 strip pretty much indicts the Post (as well as other lazy/compromised “serious” media) right up the yinyang. No wonder they want to get rid of him. Can’t have the jester speak too much truth in the king’s court with all the sycophantage to hear, can we now.
I can proudly say that I’m the one who sent Ruben Bolling an e-mail asking him about this specific toon thanks to an Alas discussion where I wanted to reference it, but couldn’t find it on the internets. He e-mailed me back saying he’d publish it this week. So, hurray.
This was the first Tom the Dancing Bug I ever read way back when I was 13. And downright brilliant, I say.
Love, love, love this! Brilliant!
Hey, when he’s right, he’s right. Good for him.
I do think this is funny, although it only partly captures the curious, quasi-scientific nature of IQ measurement.
If IQ a meaningless number, we should jettison its use across the board. It’s not just meaningless when we compare races, but always.
If we advance a claim that IQ is only meaningless when we compare races, then it’s not really a scientific claim; it’s more socially nuanced than that.
Phil, I wouldn’t mind jettisoning IQ measurement altogether, as I do think it is pretty close to being meaningless. The point of the measurement was originally to distinguish between two broad classes of people with special educational needs: those who are able to do most intellectual tasks with the same facility as anyone else but who have trouble with reading and therefore do badly in school, versus those who can’t learn to read for the same reasons that they struggle with understanding many other things that people of their age are expected to be able to understand.
It is certainly meaningless as a dick-sizing contest to show who’s the “most intelligent” among people who are perfectly competent at meeting educational goals. And it’s certainly meaningless as a metric for comparing the relative “intelligence” of large groups such as races. I don’t think it’s all that hot for categorizing people with intellectual disabilities either, but at least you can put a case for it.
Even given the most generous interpretation of what IQ measurements can tell you: it’s not meaningful for adults, it’s not meaningful for whole populations, it’s not meaningful for people of normal intelligence or better (whatever that may mean). That’s without going into whether there’s such a thing as intelligence which can be collapsed to a single variable. And I’m not even touching on the question of whether what is popularly understood by “race” actually maps onto anything biologically meaningful.
The only question I’d have about this comic is why Ruben seems to think the only people who were enslaved in the history of the world were black. If slavery was the cause of lower IQ scores, shouldn’t all previously-enslaved people have lower IQ test scores?
Individ-
Agreed; I can see how IQ could be a tool for understanding/teaching children who have a learning disability unrelated to intelligence. And I think there is such a thing as clinically low intelligence; I suppose IQ is one of the best gauges we have to determine if a defendant lacked the intellectual capacity to know what they were doing.
That said, if we put intelligence on a continuum of scientific things we understand (water freezes at 0 degrees celsius) and things we don’t understand (say, ESP, if it even exists), I’d say intelligence is somewhere in the vicinity of acupuncture and “the purpose of dreams.” It’s a big, multifaceted thing.
That said, I think it will be years or decades before this can be even discussed without dogma interfering. As you said, “race” is not a cut-and-dried biological concept. Our social construction of “races” is actually just a collection of genetic traits which are likely to occur in people whose ancestors were at one time on geographically separate parts of the globe. We take it for granted that some traits are genetic and are linked to our ancestors: being prone to sickle-cell anemia, having longer eyelashes, having red hair, etc. If intelligence is linked to our genes (and it’s a big if), then there isn’t a reason yet to assume that all of our socially constructed groupings of peoples must nonetheless have equal average intelligence.
However, we’re not at a place where even intellectuals and scientists can discuss such a possibility without political ramifications, because the misinterpretation of the data is so unsavory, with so many potential social side effects, that it makes even people who think the data are accurate to be a little queasy.
Crucially, I’d say the average American (no pun intended) doesn’t understand a lot about statistics and what they really mean.
Pingback: White privilege, as drawn by Ruben Bolling « white noise
Assuming your query was in good faith, Demonspawn, the notion of politically and economically disadvantaged minorities scoring lower on IQ tests is actually quite common:
The fact that burakumin aren’t even a separate racial or ethnic group make them an interesting case study.
I think you’re being far too generous. Racists make hay about social science and anthro, as if there was something wrong with social science and anthro, but biologists would be the first to tell you that human ‘races’ simply do not meet the taxonomic criteria of subspecies used for every other animal species when we refer to ‘race’. (The human race, strictly speaking, is far more genetically homogeneous than normal, most likely due to the Toba bottleneck.) Molecular geneticists go even further.
What’s disheartening, of course, is why all this should matter. Personally, I think that if dolphins are self-aware, they should be given special protection, and if a computer program achieves the same, to delete it to something amounting to murder. That our agreement on the concept of equal rights actually depends on a slight bump on some statistical numerical scale is truly frightening. On the other hand, I’ll admit I take comfort in the fact that science has confirmed that dishonest, immoral asshattery is also stupid and pointless.
Sorry, I didn’t include the link.
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9B01E7DB1139F933A05752C1A963958260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=all