Armchair Activist #21: protect stem cell research

I doubt its any surprise that i support stem cell research. For me, there’s really not much of a question. As you can see below, there are 71 known diseases that may be treated or cured through stem cell research. Many of these ailments affect people i know and love. How can you argue with allowing someone you love to live and to live without unnecessary pain?

Then there is the animal lib perspective. For a specific example, one of the diseases on the list is HIV/AIDS. Numerous chimpanzees and other primates have been and continue to be injected with HIV, then killed in a failed attempt to find a cure. Thing is, chimps can’t get HIV (hello, its the HUMAN immunodeficiency virus). So why are we killing so many animals to find a cure for a disease they can’t get? Well, there’s a lot of money and academic prestige in animal testing (even if you fail), but that’s another topic. (editor’s note: see comments. thanks again, RonF) Surprise, surprise, the most effective research methods are also the most humane. No one has to die in the name of stem cell research.

Yet for years, stem cell research has been attacked and its development hindered. On January 11, however, the House will vote on HR3, possibly overturning the hindrances. Because it is suspected that Bush will veto the bill if passed, StemPAC is asking people to contact their representatives to push for a two-thirds majority.

Here is StemPAC’s 71 Reasons to Support Stem Cell Research:

Discussions about stem cell research are often very scientific, but it’s important to keep our eye on the prize. Ultimately, this isn’t about blastocysts, or somatic nuclear transfer, e=mc2, dilithium crystals, etc., etc., etc., — it’s about cures. The “pro stem cell” movement is first and foremost a “pro cures” movement.

Here are 71 diseases and injuries that may be treated or cured by stem cell research. First, a caveat — this research is still in its early stages, and we’re not saying that cures are here today, or will be here next week. But we are saying this — with stem cell research, we will almost certainly get these cures and treatments sooner — a lot sooner. It’s not a promise of a cure, but it is a promise of one key thing — more hope. A lot more hope.

Okay, so here’s the list.

Autoimmune Diseases/ Musculoskeletal/ Connective Tissue Disorders

Arthritis, Crohn’s Disease, Devic’s Syndrome, Multiple Sclerosis, Osteoporosis, Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (Lupus), Systemic Sclerosis, Type 1 Diabetes

Cancers

Bladder/Kidney, Brain/Central Nervous System, Breast, Colon/Lower Bowel, Endometrium/Cervix/Ovary, Esophagus, Leukemia, Liver, Lungs/Respiratory System, Lymphoma, Myeloma, Pancreas, Prostate, Skin, Stomach

Cardiovascular Diseases

Acute Ischemic Heart Disease (angina), Myocardial Infarction (heart attack), Chronic Ischemic Heart Disease (athersclerotic heart disease), Cardiomyopathy Cerebrovascular Disease (stroke)

Circulatory/Respiratory Diseases

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, Pulmonary Fibrosis

Injuries

Severe Burns, Shaken Baby Syndrome, Spinal Cord Injury

Eye Disorders

Macular Degeneration, Retinitis Pigmentosa

Infectious Diseases

HIV/AIDS

Metabolic Diseases

Adrenoleukodystrophy, Aspartylglycosaminuria, Canavan’s Disease, Cystic Fibrosis, Fabry Disease, Fucosidosis, Gaucher Disease, Leukodystrophy, Mucopolysaccharidoses, Niemann-Pick Disease, Pompe Disease, Porphyria, Sickle Cell Disease, Tay-Sachs Disease, Type 2 Diabetes

Muscular Dystrophies

Becker, Duchenne, Emery Dreifuss, Facioscapulohumeral, Fukuyama, Limb Girdle, Myasthenia Gravis, Myotonic Dystrophy

Neurological Diseases of Adulthood

Alzheimer’s Disease, Huntington’s Disease, Lou Gehrig’s Disease (ALS), Parkinson’s Disease

Neurological Diseases of Childhood

Asperger Syndrome, Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Childhood Disintegrative Disorder, Down Syndrome, Epilepsy, Hydrocephalus, Rett Syndrome

Source: Yes on 71 – Californians for Stem Cell Research & Cures, 2004.

(NOTE: This is NOT an exhaustive scientific accounting of all potential target diseases but, rather, intended as a guide for the lay-public to use in their advocacy efforts)

*note: i am of the school of thought that some of the “diseases” on this list don’t need to be or shouldn’t be viewed as such (Autism, Down Syndrome, etc). And i do not support the forced “curing” of anyone. I have worked with children with autism and down syndrome and they were perfectly happy children. I believe we often view that which is different from ourselves as a disease, and proceed to view the “diseased” persyn as undesirable or flawed. Yet those who consent to relieving their own dis-eases deserve our full support. I do not wish to digress from the topic at hand, but merely wanted to add a clarifying note.

hat tip to quakerdave

This entry was posted in Armchair Activist. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Armchair Activist #21: protect stem cell research

  1. mcewen says:

    Maybe your clarifying point should be a little more prominent.
    Best wishes

  2. RonF says:

    Thing is, chimps can’t get HIV (hello, its the HUMAN immunodeficiency virus). So why are we killing so many animals to find a cure for a disease they can’t get?

    Not true. Chimpanzees can be infected by HIV, and they will test HIV positive. However, they do not get AIDS. The question becomes why that happens, why HIV infection leads to AIDS in humans but not chimpanzees, and how that can be used to figure out a cure for AIDS.

    There’s certainly an ethical question as to whether or not chimpanzees should be used for medical research, but there’s good scientific reasons for doing so.

    For the record, I favor stem cell research.

  3. vegankid says:

    mcewen – perhaps, but i didn’t want to draw attention away from the legislation and get caught up in a debate about disease and projected disease.

    ronf – you are right. thank you for the clarification. this isn’t the first time i’ve mistakenly mad the claim that chimps can’t get HIV, mistaking if for the fact they can’t get AIDS. although i disagree, ethically, with testing on chimps, i do understand that there are scientific reasons for doing so. point conceded. i won’t get into a debate on animal testing, ethics, and effective research methods because that’s just not the point of this post. but again, thanks for the correction.

    and of course, you don’t have to be opposed to animal testing to support stem cell research. its just a bonus for me:)

  4. Trey says:

    I too support stem-cell research (and like with any research, there should be guidelines and standards of ethics)

    I’ll be doing my arm-chair activism this week on this!

  5. Now that they’ve found embryonic stem cells in amniotic fluid, I’m waiting to see if the anti-abortion folks who argued that there wasn’t any good reason to do ESC research will change their minds.

  6. vegankid says:

    i like that kind of enthusiasm, trey!
    good question, nancy. i suspect that, in time, many will, but it can also be hard to predict people’s behavior.

Comments are closed.