- A victory for the pro-lifers today: The Senate Approves Ban on Abortion Procedure. Enjoy your victory while it lasts, is my advice to the right. Once I was very worried about this, but that was when I was assuming that O’Conner was going to retire from the Supreme Court during Bush’s first term. With O’Conner staying on the Court, however, it’s very likely that the Court is going to find this ban unconstitutional.
- Proof that not all conservatives are anti-gay: There’s a good Andrew Sullivan essay in the Wall Street Journal, criticizing other conservatives for their anti-gay attitudes.
So what is it? What exactly is the post-Lawrence conservative social policy toward homosexuals? Amazingly, the current answer is entirely a negative one. The majority of social conservatives oppose gay marriage; they oppose gay citizens serving their country in the military; they oppose gay citizens raising children; they oppose protecting gay citizens from workplace discrimination; they oppose including gays in hate-crime legislation, while including every other victimized group; they oppose civil unions; they oppose domestic partnerships; they oppose . . . well, they oppose, for the most part, every single practical measure that brings gay citizens into the mainstream of American life.
This is simply bizarre. Can you think of any other legal, noncriminal minority in society toward which social conservatives have nothing but a negative social policy? What other group in society do conservatives believe should be kept outside integrating social institutions? On what other issue do conservatives favor separatism over integration? We know, in short, what conservatives are against in this matter. But what exactly are they for?
- But then again… for a laugh, check out this response to Sullivan by David Frum, also in the WSJ. Frum argues that conservatives have no choice but to oppose gay marriage laws. Why? Because if gays can marry, the goverment will be forced to set up halfway-marriage laws, which heterosexuals will want access to, which will reduce heterosexual marraige. Why will halfway-marriage laws be necessary? Because conservatives will oppose full gay-marriage laws.
In other words – if we cut out the fuzzy middle of this logic chain, and look only at the start and end – conservatives have no choice but to oppose gay marriage laws because conservatives will oppose gay marriage laws. Oy.
- A few days ago, I mentioned the Terri Schiavo case. Today, Jeb Bush has signed a new law which will cause Schiavo to be kept alive via a tube feeder.
- Jasperboi, a non-op (I think – it’s not really my business, of course) FtM transsexual (I think) feminist – muses on the kinds of men that different parts of our society will allow/expect him to be, and also on the difficulties men can have on finding a place in feminism. Interesting stuff.
- From back in June, a very good post on Procrastination, arguing that arranged marriages have been overrated.
- Two interesting Times articles on childbearing and poverty. First, a case of a woman charged with child endangerment after her two children were murdered while she was at her job. She wasn’t able to find a baby-sitter, and she couldn’t risk being fired, so she left her two kids, ages 8 and 2, at home. While she was out, someone deliberately set her apartment on fire, killing the children. Now she’s been charged with child endangerment.
This underscores the desparate need for universal, free child-care. There’s no reason anyone should be faced with this sort of “leave your kids alone or lose your job and watch the kids starve” choice. To then charge the woman with a crime is disgusting.
Second, a new study finds that chlidren’s behavior improves as their family’s income goes up.
- Over on Body and Soul, why I’m probably voting for Kucinich in the primary.
- A really interesting essay, Free Mickey!, on an 1970s satire of Mickey Mouse that Disney attempted to sue into oblivionland.
Recent Comments
Cartoon: Deux Ex Machina, Suckers!
Cartoon: Free Speech on Campus
Cartoon: Unions Have Always Done The Impossible!
Cartoon: It's All About Caring, Fatsos
Cartoon: The Measure of Intelligence
Cartoon: Hey did you hear? Biden is old!
- Link Love | Grumpy Rumblings (of the formerly untenured) { […] Cartoon: Hey did you hear? Biden is old! […] }
- Ampersand on Apr 5, 2024 at 12:09 pm
- Avvaaa on Apr 4, 2024 at 10:27 pm
- Ampersand on Apr 4, 2024 at 6:09 pm
Cartoon: The Celestial Politics of Trans Bans
- Older »
Most Recent Open Thread
The most recent open thread can always be found at the top of this page. When older posts have closed comments, please respond to them on the most recent open thread.Alas, a Blogroll
- Lawyers Guns and Money
Unaccountable public official considers any scrutiny too much
about an hour ago - Election Law Blog
“At Justice Alito’s House, a ‘Stop the Steal’ Symbol on Display”
5 hours ago - The Incidental Economist
Is Acetaminophen Safe for Pregnant People?
5 hours ago - Family Inequality
The definitive US baby name popularity and androgyny update for 2023
3 days ago - Whipping Girl
Maintenance Phase podcast on "Social Contagion" and "ROGD"
1 week ago
- Lawyers Guns and Money
Barry’s BlueSky
- Untitled May 16, 2024It's basically impossible to parody the modern right. [contains quote post or other embedded content]
- Untitled May 16, 2024The Existence of Trains Debate #PoliCartoon #Climate #ClimateChange #GlobalWarming
- Untitled May 15, 2024Two of the most common complaints I get about my cartoons: 1) You left something out! 2) You use way too many words.
- Untitled May 15, 2024The Six Kinds of Republican #PoliCartoon
- Untitled May 15, 2024I think part of what's going on is that some people always like an excuse to be mean yet think of themselves as virtuous. (Happens on all sides, btw.) But another reason - particularly wrt Gaza - is that we feel helpless. We're stuck in "this is so horrible, I must do SOMETHING! But what?" […]
- Untitled May 15, 2024Regarding the new Hillel survey of Jewish college students, I can't find anything about their sampling methodology. But in Hillel's sample, Jews are 50% moderate or conservative. That would make Jewish undergrads far to the right of US Jews in general.
- Untitled May 16, 2024
Alas, A Subscription Service
Archives
Categories
AFAIK, that’s pretty much Sullivan’s only redeeming quality.
It’s also only nominally redeeming since he is personally affected by their bigotry. He has in the past repeated the lie that the right wasn’t that much worse than the left in these things citing Clinton’s signing of the DOMA. Can someone name some non-gay conservatives who are not homophobic bigots? (Liberal republicans (all three of them), of course, aren’t conservative, while conservative democrats are. Compare and contrast William Weld and Zell Miller (or Sam Nunn).)
a?
just a test
Pingback: Sappho's Breathing