Post request: could someone who has been following the MN Senate election and recount go through this WSJ editorial and explain what is fact, what is opinion, and what is on the level of the WSJ’s classic “isn’t it suspicious that so many people have died around Bill Clinton?” (MN recount edition: “isn’t it suspicious that most of the canvassing board’s decisions help Franken?”).
I’ve already seen the editorial on a Republican acquaintance’s Facebook feed and had it quoted to me by another conservative friend. And yes, I am too lazy to come up with my own rebuttals in fact-intensive arguments I haven’t been following closely.
“isn’t it suspicious that most of the canvassing board’s decisions help Franken?
I believe the short answer is, “No, because the canvassing board does not lean Democratic, and may actually lean Republican, yet their decisions have been largely unanimous. This indicates to me that they were likely good decisions based on the law, rather than based on helping Franken.”
I don’t think my politics have much to do with good taste. Taste is almost entirely an aesthetic concept, not a political one. After all, some of my political allies will respond to attempts to constrain women’s reproductive freedom with pictures of wire hangers, which is not precisely in good taste. Nor is sitting in an establishment where you are unwelcome — but I admire the civil disobedience of African Americans demanding an end to Jim Crow. (At the time of the sit-ins, my alma mater’s newspaper editorial board stated that the bad taste of going where one was unwanted was a good reason to oppose sit-ins.) If I cared about good taste in politics, I’d probably be a latter-day William F. Buckley.
See, I think that picking “Under My Thumb” as your parody song takes it to another level. Yes, Franken has had some misogyny issues in his past, which is a reason I wasn’t an enthusiastic backer of him (I voted for him, and am glad he won, but I wasn’t a big supporter). But I don’t see this as one of them.
Comments are closed.
Tangentially related: --they wouldn’t do that, unless they were extras in a company of The Sound of Music. --FAKE NEWS!…
When you're defending nazi salutes, you're telling me that you're a nazi.
About Elon's Nazi salute, I'll again post this video, which shows Elon's salute side by side with the salute as…
The only thing a beggar provides you with is a blessing/karma, which has no economic value, although I would still…
Well, clearly at least one does. God knows Musk doesn’t have to work another day in his life and hasn’t…
Post request: could someone who has been following the MN Senate election and recount go through this WSJ editorial and explain what is fact, what is opinion, and what is on the level of the WSJ’s classic “isn’t it suspicious that so many people have died around Bill Clinton?” (MN recount edition: “isn’t it suspicious that most of the canvassing board’s decisions help Franken?”).
I’ve already seen the editorial on a Republican acquaintance’s Facebook feed and had it quoted to me by another conservative friend. And yes, I am too lazy to come up with my own rebuttals in fact-intensive arguments I haven’t been following closely.
whoa! Franklen sang “under my thumb.” could this be his maccaca moment? alas, its too late.
I believe the short answer is, “No, because the canvassing board does not lean Democratic, and may actually lean Republican, yet their decisions have been largely unanimous. This indicates to me that they were likely good decisions based on the law, rather than based on helping Franken.”
—Myca
Huh? Explain?
—Myca
well, at least it wasn’t “brown sugar’
myca:
just joking around. but its a song famous for its misogyny. was a big 2nd wave issue, back in a the day,
“Under My Thumb” is probably my favorite Rolling Stones song. Sometimes aesthetics doesn’t match up with politics.
pg: i like sympathy for the devil…sometimes they match up perfectly.
Your political sympathy is with “a man of wealth and taste”?
Well… I would certainly be more inclined to politically link myself with a man of taste than a man of no or bad taste.
One can forgive a lack of wealth. One can never forgive a lack of taste.
Of course. Have we not met? Please allow me to introduce myself.
I don’t think my politics have much to do with good taste. Taste is almost entirely an aesthetic concept, not a political one. After all, some of my political allies will respond to attempts to constrain women’s reproductive freedom with pictures of wire hangers, which is not precisely in good taste. Nor is sitting in an establishment where you are unwelcome — but I admire the civil disobedience of African Americans demanding an end to Jim Crow. (At the time of the sit-ins, my alma mater’s newspaper editorial board stated that the bad taste of going where one was unwanted was a good reason to oppose sit-ins.) If I cared about good taste in politics, I’d probably be a latter-day William F. Buckley.
Defiance of despotic authority and racism is ALWAYS in good taste.
Anyone who disagrees suffers from bad taste. :)
Check out pics of the Hungarian Revolution. Now, that was in very good taste. All those well-dressed people in trenchcoats fighting the Evil Empire.
That should show Che who the real revolutionary fashionistas are. Though I must admit, Stalin had great hair.
Pingback: Alas, a blog » Blog Archive » Yes, We Take Requests
See, I think that picking “Under My Thumb” as your parody song takes it to another level. Yes, Franken has had some misogyny issues in his past, which is a reason I wasn’t an enthusiastic backer of him (I voted for him, and am glad he won, but I wasn’t a big supporter). But I don’t see this as one of them.