The Human Rights Campaign has released a good pamphlet (pdf link) outlining the basic case for marriage equality, and answering some common objections to same-sex marriage. Here’s a sample:
Not by a long shot. When a gay or lesbian person gets seriously ill, there is no legal document that can make their partner eligible to take leave from work under the federal Family and Medical Leave Act to provide care — because that law applies only to married couples.
When gay or lesbian people grow old and in need of nursing home care, there is no legal document that can give them the right to Medicaid coverage without potentially causing their partner to be forced from their home — because the federal Medicaid law only permits married spouses to keep their home without becoming ineligible for benefits.
And when a gay or lesbian person dies, there is no legal document that can extend Social Security survivor benefits or the right to inherit a retirement plan without severe tax burdens that stem from being “unmarried” in the eyes of the law.
These are only a few examples of the critical protections that are granted through more than 1,100 federal laws that protect only married couples. In the absence of the right to marry, same-sex couples can only put in place a handful of the most basic arrangements, such as naming each other in a will or a power of attorney. And even these documents remain vulnerable to challenges in court by disgruntled family members.
That’s just one of many subjects the pamphlet covers – it’s worth a read.
One flaw, as Gabriel Rosenberg argues, is the pamphlet’s claim of 3,136,921 same-sex couples in the US today – a number that’s simply unsupportable. From Gabriel’s post:
As Ganriel says, the Census figure is probably an undercount, but not that huge an undercount.
Gabriel also points out that (again, according to the US Census), one in five male couples and one in three female couples are raising children – and 50% of those are raising two or more childrne. On the whole, “These numbers imply at least 330,000 children being denied the protections marriage could bring their families.”
UPDATE: I just received an email from Tom Sullivan of the HRC regarding that inflated figure: “I have posted a corrected version on the website and we are looking into ways to correct the print copies (labels perhaps). All future print runs will have the correct statistics.” Cool. :-).
Not reall a comment, just a question. Is this really going to be a temporary address or should I reset my bookmark?
I dunno. For now, reset your bookmark. Sorry I can’t be more definite.
Estimates of under/overcounts are to be taken with a graint of salt. There was a big push for same-sex households to report their status in Census 2000. It is a tiny segment of the sample that received the Long Form so the results can be fudged by HRC and others who want to puff-up their case for their political agenda. Even the 5% estimate is highly questionable in terms of the marriage issue.
Very good idea. thank you free group sex pictures ee Free Lesbian Sex Stories www free preteen sex pics www Free Beastiality Sex Pics xxx free live sex feeds free ebony sex pics free video sex
Pingback: Daddy, Papa & Me