The Art of Persuasion


I’m really happy with the art in this one, especially the first two panels. In fact, because I was having so much fun drawing that double-panel background, I forgot about the word balloons and wasted some time drawing distant houses that ended up completely covered.

I’m also feeling very smug about how nicely the color scheme came out. And I know — it’s possible that I’ll hate this art when I look at it again a few years from now. But heck, I might as well try to enjoy the good feelings while they last.

(Did you catch my use of an em dash? Obviously I must be an AI!)


Two things that are true:

1) It will be awful for trans people if the Republicans win the midterms.

2) It will be awful for trans people if Democrats become anti-trans rights, and we wind up with what the UK now has: Both major parties being anti-trans.

Too many centrist Democrats arguing 1) seemingly have a hard time acknowledging 2).

My issue isn’t that some centrists disagree with trans people who are saying they’ll refuse to vote for anti-trans Democrats. I personally disagree with that tactic; so do some trans people I’ve read (trans people don’t have a groupmind). Tactical disagreements happen. They’re inevitable.

But refusing to acknowledge that there’s a problem isn’t a tactical disagreement.

I’ve seen too many centrist Dems sneering with hatred at trans people who are angry and scared by seeing some prominent Dems taking up anti-trans arguments. But why shouldn’t trans people be angry about that?

“I know — all I have to do is tell frightened people who see Dem support for their rights starting to slip away that they’re Trump-supporting morons! THEN they’ll support Dems!” is not the persuasive argument that some centrist Dems apparently believe it to be.

The prospect of the Dems moving away from their commitment to trans rights — as some prominent centrist Democrats have advised — is genuinely terrifying to trans people. And it’s too easy for cis people to say “that’ll never happen” when it’s not our rights tumbling off a cliff.

It’s striking that too many cis centrists are saying, in effect, “why can’t angry trans people just put aside their emotions and fears and think of the greater good?” when they themselves are terrible at putting their emotions aside.


If you want to read more about this issue, I recommend Julia Serano’s essay “On Democrats Who Cave in Response to Anti-Trans Attack Ads,” with the arch subtitle “and more importantly: a response to all the cis people responding to the way that trans people are responding to said Democrats’ responses.”

If you think your favorite candidate enacted the correct political strategy, then there is no reason to berate trans people for protesting it, as those protests should already be baked into your candidate’s calculations. So why are you berating trans people then? (Unless, of course, you enjoy berating trans people just for the sake of it.)

Alternatively, if you think trans people are capable of tanking your favorite candidate via our criticisms and protests, doesn’t that imply that your candidate (and their consultants and strategists) totally fucked up in their political calculations here? And if they did fuck up, shouldn’t you be reaching out and complaining to them (rather than berating trans people), in the hope that they might reverse their bad decision?

In other words, why are we blaming trans people for a decision that was made by cisgender politicians, consultants, and strategists?


TRANSCRIPT

Panel 1:
A woman and a man sit on a low stone wall in a park. The woman is upset; the man listens.

WOMAN: And now the Democrat in the race is backing some anti-trans laws! I’m not sure I can vote for that.

MAN (thinking): Uh-oh. Democrats need every vote. How can I convince her to vote for the Democrat anyway?

Panel 2:
The woman and man walk through the park, the woman ahead of him.

WOMAN: Of course, the Republican is even worse. But if Democrats turn against trans people… I’m so frightened.

MAN (thinking): I’ve got to be empathetic and persuasive.

Panel 3:
Close-up of the man, looking thoughtful with his hand on his chin.

WOMAN (off-panel): Look at what happened to the UK — they’ve now got two anti-trans parties. If we let that happen here, trans rights are dead.

MAN (thinking): Okay, I think I know how to reassure her and get her vote.

Panel 4:
The man is suddenly furious, leaning toward the startled woman and pointing at her.

MAN: You’re a Trump supporting moron and you deserve to die!

CHICKEN FAT WATCH

PANEL 1:
A good dog with a halo peers out a window. A hand sticks out of a hole in a tree holding a sign that says SEND CANDY.

PANEL 2:
Groucho peeks from behind some bushes. A poster nailed to a tree reads “Background gag to come and it’ll be so funny!” A bad rabbit (we know it’s bad because it’s smoking) sits beside a bad worm (also smoking). A bottle lying in the grass is labeled “BARRY BEER” and has a disturbed-looking drawing of Barry. A mouse holds a knife to a cat; the cat raises its front paws in surrender.

PANEL 4:
A giant mouse (?) in a shirt and tie sits on the wall reading a newspaper, called “Daily Blah Blah,” whose headline says “Literate Rodent Escapes Lab.”


The Art of Persuasion | Barry Deutsch on Patreon

 

This entry was posted in Cartooning & comics, Elections and politics, Lesbian, Gay, Bi, Trans and Queer issues, Transsexual and Transgender related issues. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Art of Persuasion

  1. beth says:

    Last year my mom got very angry that some people were planning to vote for Abigail Spanberger, but that they weren’t doing it enthusiastically. I don’t think she convinced anyone that way.

  2. Grace Annam says:

    I love this one.

    Grace

  3. Ampersand says:

    Thank you, Grace! :#)

  4. Saurs says:

    Oh man, I love the black houses and the cinematic continuity across the double panel. Completely agree with you about the color scheme; it is deliciously satisfying. I also really enjoy the qualities and movement of the man’s hair.

    Hopefully when you revisit this in future, you’ll still be pleased.

  5. Ampersand says:

    Thanks so much, Saurs! I definitely need to do those black houses again, but this time in a panel where they won’t be entirely lost behind word baloons. :-p

  6. Dave Dell says:

    Here in flyover country Nebraska an independent Senate candidate (who’ll caucus with the Democratic Party) added a no men in girls sports line to his early tv commercials. Changed my support to a “meh, I’ll still vote for him but without my contribution of money or time”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *