Welcome back to Kevin Moore, whose lovely drawings we haven’t seen here in a pig’s age! (I have no idea what a “pig’s age” means.)
Did you know that, according to the FBI, homicide rates in the US are the lowest they’ve been since 1956? Well, probably you do know that — but you’re the sort of person who’d read my cartoons on purpose, so you’re weird. Most Americans think homicide rates have been increasing.
Americans have a vastly outsized idea of how common violent crime — and, in particular, murder — is. In 2019, Ipsos asked Americans to guess what percentage of deaths in the U.S. are caused by homicide. The average guess was 8.2%. (In reality, it’s 0.7%.)
If only we had an industry devoted to making sure that Americans are well-informed about matters of public interest. It would have to be an industry other than the news industry. In 2024, Pew published a report on “The link between local news coverage and Americans’ perceptions of crime.”
There’s a clear relationship between how much local crime news Americans consume and how concerned they are about their safety. Among Americans who get local crime news often, 33% are extremely or very concerned about local crime affecting them or their family. That figure falls to 19% among those who get local news crime sometimes and 10% among those who get it rarely or never.
As Pew points out, this might be because local news tells viewers that they’re in danger (as this cartoon suggests). Or it might be that people who are already convinced that crime is omnipresent seek out crime news to confirm their views. Maybe both are true, in a vicious cycle. But there’s no way to look at this and think the news media is doing a good job informing people about crime.
Violent attacks by strangers are especially likely to be reported by the media. in 1998, a study in the American Journal of Public Health found that “some homicides are more newsworthy than others.”
Even when multiple variables were taken into account, some homicides (those with female, child, or elderly victims; those in which the suspect was a stranger to the victim; those in wealthier neighborhoods) received more coverage and others (those with Black or Hispanic victims or victims with less than a high school education; those committed with nonfirearm weapons; those in which the suspect was an intimate of the victim) received less coverage than expected.
Seniors are particularly likely to fear violent crime – even though they’re less likely to be victims of violent crime. (Seniors are also particularly likely to watch local news, but remember about correlations and causation.)
It’s pretty easy to understand why the news media is like this – it makes them money. Political scientists Franklin Gilliam Jr. and Shanto Iyengar describe the dynamic:
The drive for audience ratings pushes local news organizations to favor an ‘action news’ format. Stories about crime provide the necessary ingredients for successful marketing of newscasts – a focus on concrete events, their impact on ordinary people, drama and emotion, and, above all, attention-getting visuals.
What’s much harder than seeing the problem, unfortunately, is imagining a solution to this. News in the U.S. is almost always made for profit; news producers are under enormous pressure to attract large audiences. In this context, there’s very little incentive for new outlets to tell audiences that we have less reason to fear crime.
TRANSCRIPT OF CARTOON
This cartoon has four panels. They all show the same scene: A woman in an orange tracksuit, in a park, is talking to a red robot on tank treads. The robot has a television screen for a head, with a newsman’s face on the screen, and “NEWSBOT-5000” written on its side.
PANEL 1
The woman walks peacefully along the sidewalk. The newsbot extends a microphone toward her. The newsman on its screen looks extremely cheerful.
NEWSBOT: Hi! It’s me, the media! Have you noticed that you’re surrounded by CRIME?
WOMAN: I am?
PANEL 2
A closer shot. The woman looks increasingly nervous, touching a finger to her cheek. The newsbot leans eagerly toward her.
NEWSBOT: Yes! You’re VERY endangered! It’s VERY likely that someone is about to jump out and murder you RIGHT NOW!
PANEL 3
The woman looks around a bit nervously, but all is quiet. The newsbot watches her with a worried expression.
PANEL 4
The newsbot suddenly yells at the woman. Startled, she leaps into the air, her glasses flying off her face.
NEWSBOT: ANY SECOND NOW!
WOMAN: AAUGH!
CHICKEN FAT WATCH
“Chicken fat” is an ancient cartooning term for fun but unimportant details in the art.
Panel 1 – The sun has a face and is smoking a cig. A tree also has a rather angry-looking face. A strange one-eyed creature—who Kevin assures me is not a minion, but a little creature that he’s been doodling his whole life—pops out of the ground. And a hostile raccoon accosts a frightened rat.
Panel 3 – The one-eyed creature is now up a tree. The tree’s face now looks like the tree is napping, including some drool. The rat is offering a bottle of booze to the raccoon.
Panel 4 – The tree’s face is now awake, surprised by the Newsbot’s yelling. The one-eyed creature is all the way on the horizon. And the raccoon and rat are happily drunk together.



“If it bleeds, it leads” seems to be the motto of my local TV news stations.
And lately I notice the local sinclair station hyping up as much NYC crime as they can find, their motive being “look at how chaotic and dangerous NY is now, what with that Mamdani character running things!”
I’ve said this before… I really do believe that American Democrats have been slow-boiled into normalizing an abnormal amount of violence.
I recently helped a friend of mine from California move to Winnipeg, Manitoba. The conversations we had about the differences in culture have been both humorous (they apologized for swearing in front of me, which they didn’t think we did up here), and eye opening.
Winnipeg is a rough city, in my estimation, and every time I go back to it, it gets a little rougher. This is borne out by statistics… Their murder rate is on the rise, there are homeless encampments where there didn’t used to be, and walking the downtown core right now is a little surreal… I don’t think I’d ever seen a real life fentanyl zombie before this year, and there were groups of them out at any given time. And while I didn’t feel unsafe walking around them, I do think that it is a symptom of a problem that does lead to people in the downtown core being less safe. I feel like there are going to be many, many more freezing fatalities this winter.
My ex-American friends think I’m being cute. They point out that where they came from, things are so much worse. They talk about their murder rates, their experiences, the things they heard in the night. This matches my (admittedly limited) experience visiting the US. And they’re not wrong. Their experience mirrors the data… Winnipeg is Canada’s most unsafe large city, at about 4 murders per 100,000. LA, where they moved from, was more than 7 per 100,000. Of the 200 most populous cities in America, 130 have a higher murder rate than Winnipeg… And some of them are 20, 30, 40 murders per 100,000. The worst, Birmingham Alabama is almost 60. The way they were talking about it… It’s almost like they thought it was funny, and I’m not sure if that’s the joy of escaping, or some kind of trauma survival response, but it didn’t hit me as being healthy or normal.
It’s great, and that’s not me being sarcastic, I really do mean this: It is Great that murder rates are decreasing in America. They are still completely unacceptable. Globally… America ranks 145th, with only 60 countries (none of which you want to be compared to) having worse rates. If you have the privilege of feeling safe: Great. There are absolutely places you can be where that’s reasonable. A lot of people in your country don’t have that privilege, the news isn’t actually wrong, and making fun of it doesn’t actually make the problem go away.
I’ve lived in New Orleans, which had at that time the highest murder rate in the country. I used to jog at 10 p.m. in the summers. Never felt unsafe, not once.
When I was 37 and pregnant, I spent a week in New York, and traveled all over by subway, alone, from ten a.m. until two in the morning. That would have been 1998. Never felt unsafe, not even a little.
You want to ask yourself who wants you to feel unsafe on the streets and in the cities, and *why* they want you to feel unsafe.
(Now in small-town Alabama, where I stopped to get lunch one time, only to be harassed by three guys in baseball caps, yeah, that felt unsafe.)
There are two separate issues:
Issue One – Republicans lie constantly about crime. They say that it is at an all-time high, when it is not (the peak was in 1992). They say “Democrat” run cities are out of control, when the states with the highest crime rates are almost all run by them and lots of rural areas have higher crime rates than cities. They focus on crimes committed by immigrants and people of color, feeding racism and xenophobia when, in fact, most crime is committed by people the victim knows. They know that they benefit electorally from this fear. The only remedies they offer – cutting off immigration and harsher prison sentences – have been proven not to work. They have no interest in proven methods for reducing crime – gun safety, better education, drug treatment and so on.
However, it is very difficult to counter their attacks when, Corso is right on Issue Two.
Issue Two – Crime in the U.S. is still absurdly high and too many people in the U.S. have become numb to it. Delegar, your anecdotes are not data. Your experience is valid, but not universal. Your question:
Assumes that people are not victimized on the streets of U.S. cities, that they have no REAL reason to feel unsafe. This is exactly the sort of attitude which makes crime victims think that people on the left don’t care about them.
My experiences have been very different from yours.
I’ve been living in Australia for almost 20 years, and I can hardly describe the increase in safety that I feel over living in the U.S.. I did not realize how unsafe I felt in the U.S. until I had been in a low crime country for over a decade and really started to feel safe. This is not based on propaganda or vibes, it is my lived experience and reports from dozens of people who I have worked with and lived in community with. I am well off and have always lived in “good”, diverse neighborhoods. This is not a complete list.
NYC, 1988-1999
* I was hit outside a bar on the lower east side, because someone thought one of the people I was with hit his sister (he did not).
* I was humped on my commute into Manhattan from Brooklyn (where I only lived for six months) multiple times (they take advantage of the amount of people on at rush hour and the time it takes to go under the river). Calling out tended to get you a second participant, not a helper. These were my only bad experiences on the subway over the course of over a decade.
* I was groped a couple times, in Greenwich village, when out at night, by men clearly trying to pick fights with my boyfriend (who wisely did not take the bait, and just got us out of the situation).
* My neighbors in Hell’s Kitchen, who lived there in the 1970’s and 80’s reported walking down the middle of the street because they’d get mugged if they walked on the sidewalk, and not feeling safe sitting on the stoop on hot summer evenings (by the time I moved there in the mid-1990’s the neighborhood was gentrifying and you could feel the relief and euphoria of long-time residents able to go out safely again).
Chicago – summer 1991
* There were sex workers in the parking lot of the place I was working doing data entry who would break into people’s cars.
* The people I worked with reported needing to sleep on the floor when the Bulls won because people were shooting off guns.
St. Louis, 1999-2000
* I had a friend who was mugged.
* I participated in National Night Out along with people from an adjacent higher-crime neighborhood and heard a lot of stories that evening. The fact that National Night Out is even a thing speaks volumes.
Pasadena (outside LA), 2000-2008
* Street harassment was relentless, RELENTLESS. Much worse than NYC (where it was definately a thing that happened).
* Daughter of my neighbor burgled my house with her boyfriend (drugs problem, her parents were lovely, and mortified).
* Three people shot in a gang confrontation in the alley behind my house.
Pittsburgh, visiting Fall 2004
* Son went to daycare at the Jewish Community Center. There was a bomb threat and the children were evacuated.
More recently, visiting the U.S., I happened to be there when there was a mass shooting on the highway near my sister’s house in Maine (about 2023, I think), and my brother-in-law was locked down in his basement with my nieces. They had to lock down a second time at some point since then. They live in a very affluent community. If it can happen there (twice!) it can happen anywhere.
Since moving to Australia, I have been groped once (in front of my husband, guy looking for a fight). Part of this is certainly my age – I turned 40 shortly after moving here. My son’s female friends unfortunately report similar problems with groping. I think groping is a problem everywhere, and even being made worse by manosphere influencers.
But, the more violent incidents here in Australia are so rare that every gun shot victim and conveinence store hold-up makes national news (our population is similar to that of Texas for context – is every shooting in Houston reported in El Paso and vice versa – I suspect not). No one I work with (who mostly live in much less affluent areas than I do) report issues like the people who I met in New York, Chicago and St. Louis did.
I do not know the answer. But, denial doesn’t work.
My lived experience is anecdotal but yours is data?
I’m not saying crime doesn’t happen. I’m saying the unreasonable fear of crime that has been installed in Americans serves a purpose.
I agree with you that the ready access to guns is a problem we need to solve.
But not one worthy of reasonable fear?
I never claimed my experience was data. You responded to Corso’s data with anecdotes. But, he was right that the U.S. tolerates a violent crime rate far, far higher than that in other developed countries. I presented my experience to try to show that I, personally, have reasons to fear crime in the U.S.. Can you really not understand why someone with my experiences would be pissed off when confronted with the question:
Two things can be true at once – the right ramps up and exploits fear of crime in the U.S. in ways that are downright dangerous, leading to attrocities like those being committed in our names in ICE detention facilities; and crime is actually a serious problem in the U.S. (although not when compared to the U.S. from 1970-1995). These are not contradictions.
Although, to be frank, when I lived in the U.S., I basically had your attitute. I was numb to what was going on around me. I saw everything listed above as isloated incidents and just tried not to think about them. It was only when I was out of that environment for a long time that I was able to recoginize how toxic it is.
Kate, I’m really sorry you went through all that. It sucks, and I’m glad you’re in a better place (literally) now.
Two things that I believe are both true:
1) Crime in the U.S. is genuinely bad, relative to other countries, and some degree of fear is justified.
2) A lot of Americans have an unrealistic idea of how common violent stranger crime is. To use an extreme example, once someone told me that a white person wouldn’t dare set foot in Harlem because any white person in Harlem would be violently assaulted and maybe murdered, and they were being serious.
The National Crime Victimization Survey (which includes events not reported to police) found that about 1 in 130 Americans experience violence by a stranger per year. (That includes all kinds of violence, including threats that didn’t escalate into physical contact.) That’s not nothing, but it’s also a lot less than what many Americans imagine. It’s not directly comparable, but a 2019 survey found that 26% of Americans think they are likely to be physically assaulted by a stranger. (It’s not directly comparable because There was no bounding time period in the survey). (To be honest, I’m not sure how much I trust that survey). A 2010 study found that Americans though there was a 1 in 7 (average) or 1 in 10 (median) chance they’d be robbed through force in the next year; the actual annual victimization rate among the respondents was 1 in 83.
(I’m not assuming that you disagree with me about any of this, Kate. Reading your comment it’s obvious we agree on quite a lot.)
That’s funny! I lived in Harlem for years. Washington Heights was way scarier.
I lived in Harlem for a little bit too! Maybe we ran into each other there.
I taught at City College.
So did my dad, I think!
I think you need to demonstrate that the fear is unreasonable…. Amp took a swing at that by pointing out that people in America assume that bad things will happen to them at a higher incidence rate than will actually occur. I think that it’s fair to say that might be indicative that something is stoking fear, but I’m still not sold that the fear is actually unreasonable. Or maybe that even if it is, it might be reasonable to act as if it weren’t. It’s very human to be risk adverse and to extrapolate worst case scenarios onto ourselves. We have entire industries devoted to mitigating low-frequency high-impact risks… It’s why we wear seatbelts despite most people never being in a vehicular accident needing one. Wearing a seatbelt isn’t unreasonable.
I meant what I originally said: I think that it is very hard, maybe even approaching qualia, for someone born and raised in America to understand how abnormal your violence levels are without experiencing significant time outside America.