America’s Biggest Problem


Another collaboration with gorgeous visuals from R.E. Ryan.


University of Amsterdam professor Petter Törnberg wrote an article that could have been written to go with this cartoon: It’s Not Polarization; It’s the Radicalization of the Political Right.

Polarization offers an ostensibly neutral frame, distributing blame evenly across the political spectrum. Much like journalism’s “both-sides” logic, its scholarly embrace allows analysts to diagnose dysfunction without appearing partisan. […]

Yet this neutrality is not borne out by the empirical evidence. Across advanced democracies, crisis is resulting not from mutual divergence but from the one-sided transformation of the political right: the mainstreaming of authoritarian rhetoric, the normalization of conspiracy and hate as political strategies, and the systematic dismantling of institutional guardrails. […]

Refusing to name asymmetry is itself a political act. To continue describing democratic crisis as polarization is to lend legitimacy to those undermining democracy by treating them as one half of a symmetric dynamic. Neutrality under these conditions is not objectivity: it is complicity.

Törnberg’s article is about scholars, whereas my cartoon is about journalists and pundits, but the same analysis applies. A certain kind of personality likes finding a way to blame both sides no matter what the conflict is. It lets them — or “us,” I should say, since my personality definitely includes this flaw — feel like our analysis is smarter, our viewpoint fairer, and our insights deeper.

And yet, so many of the stupidest ideas I’ve heard have come from people who proudly declare themselves above taking sides.

To quote Thomas Zimmer (as I’ll do a lot in this post):

The “polarization” concept is useful if you want to sound serious by lamenting the state of American politics but don’t understand or deliberately want to obscure the fact that the major threat to democracy is a radicalizing Right.

It’s certainly good to be able to criticize both parties. But viewing everything through a polarization lens can be as distorting as viewing everything through a partisan lens.

Commenting on Ezra Klein’s Why We’re Polarized, Thomas Zimmer points out that Klein, in the final section of his book, admits that it’s the Republicans who have changed — but still attempts to cling to “polarization.”

To account for these rather crucial differences between Left and Right, Klein employs the concept of “asymmetrical polarization.” But that doesn’t really solve the problem. Even when it comes with the qualifier “asymmetric,” the term “polarization” still implies both sides moving towards the extremes at least to a somewhat significant degree – and that is certainly how the term is used in the broader public discourse and understood in widely accepted parlance today. But based on the evidence Ezra Klein himself presents, there is no liberal version of Fox News and the rightwing media bubble, the Democrats don’t have a Trump, and there is no equivalent on the Left to the influence of reactionary and white nationalist forces inside the GOP. If, by the authors’ own standards, de-emphasizing the concept of “asymmetric polarization” and instead foregrounding the idea of a radicalization of the conservative movement and the GOP would capture the central development in recent U.S. history and politics more adequately and precisely, why doesn’t he?

From what I’ve seen, Klein is the best of the “polarization is the problem” pundits, but that’s perhaps not the highest bar to clear.

And as Zimmer said on Bluesky, it’s no surprise that the “polarization” analysis has been seized upon by conservatives, who recognize the value to their cause of prioritizing the “value” of depolarization over values like democracy and anti-bigotry.


TRANSCRIPT OF CARTOON

This cartoon has four panels. The same bespectacled, bearded man appears in all four.

PANEL 1

The man walks past several masked ICE agents. Two agents are dragging an older man toward the open back of an SUV. Nearby, a distressed woman stands with a small child who is crying. An ICE agent is pointing a gun at the child.

MAN (thought): Hmmm.

PANEL 2

Outside the Supreme Court, several Supreme Court justices in black robes are drinking and celebrating around a bonfire in which the Voting Rights Act is burning. The man walks past in the background, watching them.

MAN (thought): Hmm.

PANEL 3

At a bus stop, a woman is reading a newspaper. The man stands beside her, leaning slightly to read the front page. The newspaper’s main headline says: ANOTHER COMPLETELY UNAUTHORIZED UNNECESSARY WAR

MAN (thought): Mm-hmm.

PANEL 4

We see an open laptop. On its screen, the man is appearing on a TV interview show, grinning as he holds up a copy of his book, Polarization: Both Sides Did It!

MAN: America’s biggest problem is… POLARIZATION!

CHICKEN FAT WATCH

In panel 2, the burning Voting Rights Act is depicted as the “I’m Just a Bill” character from Schoolhouse Rock!

In panel 3, the newspaper is called The Daily Gab. Under the enormous war headline is a much smaller headline: “Study: No one reads smaller headlines or studies.” A sub-headline says “‘My life is pointless,’ says sub-headline writer.”

On the wall in panel 3, graffiti includes tags from all eight captains from Star Trek shows (Pike, Kirk, Janeway, Burnham, Freeman, Picard, Sisko, and Archer) plus Taggart from Galaxy Quest. Other graffiti includes “Skitter Lives!” with a spider; a huge “BG,” for “background”; and “Never obey! I order U not to obey!” It only occurs to me now, writing this transcript, that I should have made it “not 2 obey.” Oh well.

In panel 4, behind the laptop, a large orange cat is sleeping. Curled up asleep on the cat’s tail is a tiny mouse wearing a sleeping cap.


America’s Biggest Problem | Barry Deutsch on Patreon

This entry was posted in Cartooning & comics, Media criticism. Bookmark the permalink.

45 Responses to America’s Biggest Problem

  1. RonF says:

    “Outside the Supreme Court, several Supreme Court justices in black robes are drinking and celebrating around a bonfire in which the Voting Rights Act is burning.”

    Here’s Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act as amended:

    (a) No voting qualification or prerequisite to voting or standard, practice, or procedure shall be imposed or applied by any State or political subdivision in a manner which results in a denial or abridgement of the right of any citizen of the United States to vote on account of race or color, or in contravention of the guarantees set forth in section 10303(f)(2) of this title, as provided in subsection (b).

    (b) A violation of subsection (a) is established if, based on the totality of circumstances, it is shown that the political processes leading to nomination or election in the State or political subdivision are not equally open to participation by members of a class of citizens protected by subsection (a) in that its members have less opportunity than other members of the electorate to participate in the political process and to elect representatives of their choice. The extent to which members of a protected class have been elected to office in the State or political subdivision is one circumstance which may be considered: Provided, That nothing in this section establishes a right to have members of a protected class elected in numbers equal to their proportion in the population.”

    If you read through the VRA it has a LOT to say (and justifiably so) about protecting the individual right to vote against attempts from either government or private individuals to restrict it. But note the last sentence of Section 2. It seems to me that precludes the existence of a right to have a set number of minority-majority districts.

  2. RonF says:

    “… there is no equivalent on the Left to the influence of reactionary and white nationalist forces inside the GOP.”

    You don’t think the DSA qualifies?

  3. Ampersand says:

    Why do you think that? The last sentence is about who is elected – not who votes.

    Nothing about minority-majority districts obligates the voters in those districts to elect people of a particular race; those districts are just a tool to make sure that in certain circumstances, voters in protected classes have an equal opportunity to elect representatives of their choice. They’re free to choose white representatives if they want.

  4. Ampersand says:

    You don’t think the DSA qualifies?

    The influence of the DSA on the Democratic party is trivial compared to the enormous, even transformational, influence of Trumpism on the Republican party.

    There are a grand total of 2 DSA members in Congress (AOC and Tlaib).

  5. Kate says:

    You don’t think the DSA qualifies?

    In addition to what Amp said, the DSA is not authoritarian. However much you may disagree with their agenda, they will respect the results of elections and comply with court orders.
    What positions of the DSA do you see as parallel to MAGA positions?

  6. RonF says:

    those districts are just a tool to make sure that in certain circumstances, voters in protected classes have an equal opportunity to elect representatives of their choice.

    But that’s my point. That last sentence says that Section 2 does not provide such a tool. It says that there is to be no barrier preventing the nomination or election of individual people in protected classes. But they are talking about barriers being applied to individual members of those protected classes; that there are no racist mechanisms setting different nomination requirements for people of different races or ethnicities, preventing them from gathering signatures on nomination forms, refusing to accept the forms, refusing to put their names on the ballot, etc. That last sentence means that the law does not mean that State governments are required to create majority-minority districts in an attempt to ensure that minorities are actually elected. If people who are members of protected classes are as free to vote as anyone else, are as free to vote for whoever is on the ballot as anyone else, and are as free to attempt to get on to the ballot and run for office as other people are then the VRA is satisfied. The VRA was not meant to guarantee that minorities are actually elected, and that last sentence was meant to make that clear. A recognition of that by the Supreme Court means they are not gutting or burning the VRA, they are abiding by it.

    If you want to change that the proper remedy is to get the law changed by Congress, not to have the Supreme Court act as a super-legislature and read things into the law that the law itself forbids.

  7. Dianne says:

    @ron:

    You don’t think the DSA qualifies?

    In a word, no. I have yet to hear a major member of the DSA telling people to cheat like hell, babble on about furry pilots, or call for “research” into ideas that are thoroughly disproven already. So, no, not even close to the equivalent of mainstream Republicans, much less their extremists.

  8. RonF says:

    [Bigoted comment by Ron deleted. –Amp]

  9. RonF says:

    I just re-read my post. What was bigoted? You have my e-mail.

  10. Ampersand says:

    Did you receive the email I sent you yesterday?

    If yes, then in the email I marked the part that was bigoted.

    If no, you didn’t receive it, then perhaps the email I have for you is out of date. (It’s AOL).

    Either way, you should email me – barry.deutsch@gmail.com – if you want to continue discussing this.

  11. Corso says:

    On the VRA specifically… Ron is probably right. This is a case where equality feels like discrimination when you’re used to privilege.

    It bears note that this is only possible as a conversation because African Americans tend to vote overwhelmingly for Democrats. If African Americans had voting patterns more in line with almost any other demographic in America, it would be harder, possibly impossible, to do this exercise, because you couldn’t predict electoral results based solely on race.

    And I’m not saying that to make the point that they’re wrong to vote the way they are, but I would hazard a guess that if African Americans monolithically voted Republican, Democrats wouldn’t be so eager to defend maximizing their voting efficiency by race, and Republicans probably would.

    And that’s because the point of this exercise isn’t actually racial enfranchisement so much as it’s a way to force favorable gerrymandering in situations where you normally couldn’t. As opposed to all other gerrymandering which is controlled by the party in power using historical polling data to maximize voting efficiency, Democrats specifically, using race as a tool, are able to request electoral segregation in such a way as to maximize their voting efficiency regardless of what party is in power because unlike “normal” gerrymandering, this gerrymandering is based on the “enfranchisement” of a “protected class”.

    This was obviously not what the VRA intended. Ron is right… The point of the VRA was to make sure that people were able to participate in elections on an equal basis regardless of race, not to guarantee racial outcomes. There are a lot of people in a lot of states that are disenfranchised by gerrymandering, and the people disenfranchised tend to be of the opposite party of the party in power. That’s ugly, I’d support legislation that uniformly tried to control against that, but it’s race neutral in intent, even if in areas where Democrats are disenfranchised it disproportionately effects African Americans.

    Another way to look at it would be to granularize it… Groups don’t have rights, individuals have rights.

    Even though African Americans overwhelmingly vote for Democrats, there’s still some 10-20% that vote Republican. By electorally segregating black people together to maximize Democrat seats, you’re purposefully disenfranchising those 10-20% of black people, and you’re doing it by race. I don’t know how you square that circle… How do you justify purposefully diluting the voting power of African American Republicans by segregating them racially?

  12. Watcher says:

    Wow, Corso agrees with Ron! Now there’s a shock!

  13. RonF says:

    I don’t know how you square that circle…

    Illinois used to have a way to do that. It used to have multi-member districts for the Illinois State House. There were 59 House districts in the State. Three representatives were elected from each district. If more than 3 people ran, the 3 who got the most votes were elected. The key was that as a voter, your vote counted for 3 votes no matter how many candidates (up to 3) that you voted for.

    The result was that in districts where there was a sizable minority party, the majority would spread their votes over 2 or 3 candidates (each getting credit for 1.5 votes or 1 vote, respectively), whereas the minority would tend to vote for only one candidate from their party (called a “bullet vote”), who would get 3 votes from each voter. That generally resulted in 2 representatives from one party and one – the recipient of the bullet votes – from the other. Everyone in the district was thus represented.

    This was gotten rid of after a campaign led by Patrick Quinn (a Democrat who held various positions in State government) to cut back the number of representatives and thus the size of Illinois’ government. The League of Women Voters endorsed it as well. The result, coupled with gerrymandering (which would be somewhat less effective in multi-member districts), has been to heavily skew Illinois’ government so that it is now dominated by Democrats. For example, Illinois voted 54:43::Harris:Trump, but it’s representation in the Federal House is 14:3::D:R (=82%:18%), and it’s State House representation is 78:40::D:R (=66%:34%).

  14. RonF says:

    So, as Corso’s post shows, SCOTUS’ interpretation of the VRA’s Section 2 did not “gut” it. It was in accordance with both the plain text and the intent of the law. The claims otherwise by the Democrats is political theater intended to inflame their base but is in actual fact a lie.

  15. beth says:

    Obviously the shock felt or not felt by Amptoons commenters is the biggest problem facing America right now.

    Do I have to say this is sarcasm?

  16. Ampersand says:

    Ron, before I approve any more comments from you on this thread, please answer my questions. In case you missed it, here you go again.

    Did you receive the email I sent you yesterday?

    If yes, then in the email I marked the part that was bigoted.

    If no, you didn’t receive it, then perhaps the email I have for you is out of date. (It’s AOL).

    Either way, you should email me – barry.deutsch@gmail.com – if you want to continue discussing this.

    At the very least, I’m concerned that you think I have a current email from you, when apparently I do not. (Or if I do, you’ve chosen to ignore me.)

  17. RonF says:

    Amp and Kate:

    I’ve seen many people claim that Trump must have cheated to win both in 2016 and 2024. Trump abides by court orders once he’s exhausted his appeals (which is his right). I realize that in previous posts that I didn’t comment on it’s been held that the GOP has lurched to the right but that the Democrats have not lurched to the left, but I think that’s laughable. Immigration is just one example; you can pull up quotes from Biden, Obama, and both Clintons about how the border needed to be tightened and that illegal immigration needed to be stopped. But when Biden became President we got flooded with them. Frankly, I’m of the opinion that Biden never really had his hands on the levers of government – he was (especially in his last two years) a figurehead. I’m old enough to remember the Kennedy administration. My viewpoint is that saying that the Democratic party hasn’t lurched to the left is simply not a serious position.

    The influence of the DSA on the Democratic party is trivial compared to the enormous, even transformational, influence of Trumpism on the Republican party.

    Can you tell me what you mean by “Trumpism”? It’s not a term I’ve seen before.

    Trivial? The need to get their members and sympathizers to go to the polls has led to the point that the Democrats can no longer as a party outright condemn socialism.

    There are a grand total of 2 DSA members in Congress (AOC and Tlaib).

    I expect that to change after the elections this year.

    What positions of the DSA do you see as parallel to MAGA positions?

    The DSA wants to eliminate the Senate, abolish the Electoral College, replace the President and Supreme Court with an executive and judiciary chosen by and subordinate to Congress, extend full voting rights to all permanent U.S. residents, establish public ownership of the largest corporations and essential industries (it’s not clear what they term “essential”), and grant Statehood to Washington D.C. instead of simply retroceding its current residential districts to Maryland as was done for the original part of it that was south of the Potomac River back to Virginia in 1848.

    By “permanent residents” I don’t know if they just mean people with green cards or if they include people who have been here illegally for “x” amount of time as well.

    What do you see as being as radical as that from any organized group with members running for or actually elected to Congress that are backing Trump?

  18. Corso says:

    Y’know…. I don’t know that I’ve ever commented on how unsurprising it might be for some of the people here to agree with each other, even though their opinions are so cookie-cutter conformist progressive that it’s kind of funny. There’s a saying about rocks and glass houses.

  19. Ampersand says:

    I’ve seen many people claim that Trump must have cheated to win both in 2016 and 2024.

    How many of those people are high-up members of Democratic administrations, or are themselves Democratic Presidents? Can you name anyone nominated by a Democrat to be a federal judge who has refused to acknowledge that Trump legitimately won those elections?

  20. Ampersand says:

    Yes, Watcher probably should have not posted that; it didn’t add anything to the discussion, imo.

    But at least it wasn’t outright insulting, like “even though their opinions are so cookie-cutter conformist progressive that it’s kind of funny.”

    Corso, it’s completely normal for progressives to agree with other progressives on most issues, and for conservatives to agree with conservatives on most issues. This is, in fact, how we usually identify who is progressive and who is conservative.

    I realize it’s commonplace for conservatives and liberals to insult each other for being cookie cutter conformists for this perfectly normal behavior that both sides exhibit. (And arguably I’ve done it myself.). But it’s tiresome and I’d rather not do it here in Alas comments.

  21. Corso says:

    I actually thought Beth’s comment was worse than Watcher’s, although neither were necessary.

    I’ve said before that I have a fundamental inability to not let something go, I suspect it’s my brand of undiagnosed autism. I’m also a mirror, if I feel like people are being shitty to me, I’m more than willing to respond in kind, often without the fig leaf of propriety. I can guarantee to you that I’ll never make a comment like that first, and I’ll try to damn with subtle praise more kindly.

  22. Ampersand says:

    I actually thought Beth’s comment was worse than Watcher’s, although neither were necessary.

    I don’t think a “whose comments were worse” discussion is one that I want to read, or to moderate, and would ask everyone to avoid it.

  23. Kate says:

    I’ve seen many people claim that Trump must have cheated to win both in 2016 and 2024.

    There is no election denial among Democratic officials remotely comparable to the Republican Party’s wholesale refusal to accept the results of the 2020 election.*

    Trump abides by court orders once he’s exhausted his appeals (which is his right).

    This is simply untrue. According to the Guardian:

    In the first 15 months since Trump returned to the White House, district court judges ruled the administration was violating an order in at least 31 lawsuits over a wide range of issues, including mass layoffs, deportations, spending cuts and immigration practices, the AP’s review found. That’s about one out of every eight lawsuits in which courts have at least temporarily blocked the administration’s actions.
    …
    The Trump administration violations in the 31 lawsuits are in addition to more than 250 instances of noncompliance that judges, some appointed by Democratic presidents, some by Republicans, have recently highlighted in individual immigration petitions – from failing to return property to keeping immigrants locked up past court-ordered release dates.

    This is unprecidented, even compared to Trump’s first term.

    Immigration is just one example; you can pull up quotes from Biden, Obama, and both Clintons about how the border needed to be tightened and that illegal immigration needed to be stopped. But when Biden became President we got flooded with them.

    The Democratic Party has not “lurched” anywhere on immigration. It has been profoundly divided for decades, and it still is.

    * Even though they have far greater reason to claim it, at least in 2016. According to the FBI, Russia interfered in the U.S. Elections on behalf of Donald Trump in 2016.

  24. Watcher says:

    “Can you tell me what you mean by “Trumpism”? It’s not a term I’ve seen before.”

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trumpism

    ” you can pull up quotes from Biden, Obama, and both Clintons about how the border needed to be tightened”

    You can also pull up quotes from conservatives stating that there was an “open border” under Obama.

  25. Kate says:

    What do you see as being as radical as that from any organized group with members running for or actually elected to Congress that are backing Trump?

    refusal to comply with the rule of law
    This is my absolute number one issue. Denying the legitimacy of the 2020 election, violating court orders, illegally firing public officials (eg. FBI agents assigned to work on cases against Trump with Jack Smith), refusing to spend funds as allocated by congress, to list a few. No congressional Republicans are standing up to the Trump Administration on any of these points.

    ICE Abuses
    ICE racially profiling people, often detaining U.S. citizens (more than 500 according to this report). ICE abusing, and in some cases killing, protesters. Conditions in ICE detention facilities. Deporting people to third party countries, where they know no one and don’t even know the language.
    Threats of large scale “denaturalization”.

    Shutting down USAID

    It is estimated that hundreds of thousands of people have already died as a result of the cutting of USAID. Domestically, this hit farmers hard as well, as the food for food aid was purchased from U.S. Farmers. To top it all off, this was done in violation of U.S. law, as the funds for these programs had been appropriated by congress.

  26. Dianne says:

    But when Biden became President we got flooded with them

    The number of immigrants to the US went up during the first two years that Biden was in office. Hmm…what else happened during that time? Oh, right, the COVID vaccine. There was a steep decrease in the number of immigrants during the COVID pandemic, which rebounded afterwards. Perhaps you’re mistaking a return to normal for a “flood”.

  27. Dianne says:

    BTW, my impression is that since 2025, the US has been losing academics to other countries. Fewer students want to come to US universities, fewer professors are willing to take jobs at US universities, etc. I don’t have numbers on this, but the anecdotal evidence is consistent at every university where I have enough contacts to hear gossip. It makes sense: I certainly wouldn’t come to the US for any reason other than the most desperate of needs if I were from another country. Who would willingly move to a country where you might be thrown in a concentration camp at any moment?

  28. Ampersand says:

    This article – from the very right-wing[*] Cato Institute – makes a good case that blaming Biden for the immigration crisis is not justified.

    Biden – judged only by actions, not by rhetoric – was about as anti-illegal-immigration a President as we’ve had, in my lifetime at least. (Which is something I’d criticize Biden for.) And was more successful at deterring undocumented immigration than Trump was in his first term. (Trump’s second term has deterred immigration in general, including legal immigration, which will do huge economic harm to the US).

    Frankly, much of the problem was caused by things out of any US Presidents’ control. Republicans tend to think that all a President has to do is wave a wand saying “get tough” and that fixes all immigration problems, but in fact immigration is one of the thorniest and most complex policy problems that exist, and anyone claiming simple solutions exist is ignorant. (As an aside, any fix is inherently temporary, because immigration is driven by the frequently changing international context).

    One big problem was Title 42, which – as implemented under Trump and Biden – created a perverse incentive for migrants to cross the border over and over, since being expelled carried fewer legal consequences than ordinary deportation. Biden tried to end Title 42 in 2022, but Republican state attorneys general sued, and the courts blocked his administration from ending the policy until 2023.

    Biden is partially responsible for that – he continued Trump’s idiotic policy for a year before he tried to change it – but the responsibility there is primarily Republicans’, since they both began the problem and sued to stop Biden from fixing it.

    [*] Libertarian right, not religious right.

  29. Corso says:

    Kate:

    In the first 15 months since Trump returned to the White House, district court judges ruled the administration was violating an order in at least 31 lawsuits over a wide range of issues, including mass layoffs, deportations, spending cuts and immigration practices, the AP’s review found. That’s about one out of every eight lawsuits in which courts have at least temporarily blocked the administration’s actions.

    To be fair to Trump… There were some district court judges that went insane after his second election. Best example is probably James Boasberg. You may know that name from the recent Jack Smith Senate hearing, because that’s the judge that Cruz said Smith went to and issued illegal warrants for something like 200 Republican lawmakers. Specifically on Trump, he was the judge that told the administration to “turn the places around” when the administration was deporting Venezuelan gang members, but never actually put it in his order, and then tried to hold members of the administration in contempt. Boasberg asked the administration who specifically had “disobeyed” his order… Which was hard to answer because the answer was “no one” seeing as he never actually put the instructions in his written order, and he was the wrong kind of judge in the wrong kind of court to be making that order. But the administration gave him a name: They said that it was Kristy Noem that authorized the departures and she made no effort to redirect the planes. Instead of taking that and charging Noem with contempt (because he knew he’d lose), Boasberg subpoenaed half the administration, including Trump, for “additional information”, which again, he had no authority to do, and no reason to do, because he was way out over his skis, and the Administration had already given him a name. It ended up that the Administration successfully petitioned an appeals court to halt the proceedings and a writ of mandamus was issued… Which is rare to the point of almost being unheard of for a judge, a complete rebuke from a superior court basically saying that you are so far outside the law that they’re taking the case away from you, and he’s managed to rack up several of them.

    Trump is a problem. I’m not going to defend even most of his antics… But I wouldn’t count on the gravitas of unelected, black robed, tyrannical, inferior, federal district, trial court judges to make the case against him. No one is acting particularly well in these cases, and the judges are a more lasting problem than Trump is, because they don’t face term limits or elections. You’ll believe me the next time a Democrat is in power, because Trump has been stacking these courts with his sycophants, so the shoe will be on the other foot soon.

    Amp:

    Biden – judged only by actions, not by rhetoric – was about as anti-illegal-immigration a President as we’ve had, in my lifetime at least. (Which is something I’d criticize Biden for.) And was more successful at deterring undocumented immigration than Trump was in his first term. (Trump’s second term has deterred immigration in general, including legal immigration, which will do huge economic harm to the US).

    When we talk specifically about illegal immigration, you’re right in that Biden was better than Trump’s first term in action, but not rhetoric. I’m unclear on why you would criticize his anti-illegal immigrant policies though. Why is taking action against illegal immigration bad? Is that a full-chested defense of illegal immigration?

    Or is it that taking a stance against illegal immigration is good, but the mixed messaging was bad, because I could agree with that: The criticism that I would make is that the disconnect between action and rhetoric meant that people at least thought that there was a friendly environment for illegal immigration into America and therefore the flow of people to the border ramped up significantly during the Biden years, which ended up functioning like a baited trap. That wasn’t good for America, and it wasn’t good for the people making the journey, who expended resources that they couldn’t afford to chase a promise that wasn’t real.

    In that, I think that Trump’s border policy is actually probably more humane than Biden’s was…. He’s signaled that the border is closed, and people aren’t coming to it. His first quarter in office, he reduced the number of encounters by like 95%, which was something that Biden said was impossible without his bloated border bill. That problem, specifically, really was as easy as waving a magic wand and saying “get tough”.

    On the subject of legal immigration, I think you’re probably right. America is on track to take in less than a half million people legally this year, and there’s a school of thought that says that it might be ok as a correction to the previous levels of increased immigration… But I’m not sold. The problem with the years when we took too many people in (we being a lot of Western Countries) is that we lowered our collective standards to do that, we brought in a lot of unskilled, uneducated labor. Correcting against that by lowering immigration rates doesn’t work because those unskilled, uneducated laborers aren’t going to skill up to replace the immigrants displaced by the cutbacks.

  30. Dianne says:

    You’ll believe me the next time a Democrat is in power, because Trump has been stacking these courts with his sycophants, so the shoe will be on the other foot soon.

    I guess you haven’t been following the Supreme Court’s rulings lately.

    The problem with the years when we took too many people in (we being a lot of Western Countries) is that we lowered our collective standards to do that, we brought in a lot of unskilled, uneducated labor.

    I know this is going to sound sarcastic, sorry about that, but my first thought on reading that was “huh?” What evidence is there that “we” have taken in too many people and what are the ill effects? Especially given the current panic about not having enough children, it seems to me that we need to take in more people. Without immigration, everything in the US at least falls apart. We already don’t have enough people to fill roles from farmhands to medical assistants to teachers to doctors because of restrictions on immigration. And we’re rapidly losing competitiveness academically and technically.

    I agree that illegal immigration is a problem. But the problem is that people who enter legally are vulnerable to mistreatment. There needs to be a simple path to legal immigration. Somewhere upwards of 99% of immigrants are ambitious people willing to work hard to make a better life for themselves and their families. We should be encouraging them to come and make our countries better, not throwing them in concentration camps.

  31. Watcher says:

    “Especially given the current panic about not having enough children, it seems to me that we need to take in more people.”

    The whole “have more children” thing slots in very nicely with the anti-immigration thing, because it’s a dogwhistle. The implicit but very clear assumption among the racists who are the desired target of this rhetoric is that it’s not enough to just have a certain amount of people, they have to be the -right- people, e.g. people who gained citizenship by birth rather than application.

    “Especially given the current panic about not having enough children, it seems to me that we need to take in more people.”

    I honestly can’t number the amount of times people have answered this, but you continue to ask it. I assume because you want to posture as open minded and reasonable while we mad lefties shriek and yell inchoherently at you, the innocent conservative honestly seeking a conversation that we are physiologically incapable of giving you due to our cultural marxist brainwashing.

  32. Corso says:

    Dianne:

    I know this is going to sound sarcastic, sorry about that, but my first thought on reading that was “huh?” What evidence is there that “we” have taken in too many people and what are the ill effects?

    The sentences before the one you quoted were:

    I think you’re probably right. America is on track to take in less than a half million people legally this year, and there’s a school of thought that says that it might be ok as a correction to the previous levels of increased immigration… But I’m not sold.

    My point was that even if you were of the mind that America took in too many people and the decrease to immigration was a correction, the correction wouldn’t work because of the skills mismatch. More than that, I specified “we” to be a lot of Western Nations, as opposed to America, because I don’t know that America necessarily took too many people in, but I absolutely know that there are countries that did, like Canada and the UK, and in those cases, I still don’t think we should reduce our immigration rates lower than the previous normal immigration rates because we’d run into the shortfalls like the ones you were talking about.

    Especially given the current panic about not having enough children, it seems to me that we need to take in more people.

    Who made that argument?

    We already don’t have enough people to fill roles from farmhands to medical assistants to teachers to doctors because of restrictions on immigration. And we’re rapidly losing competitiveness academically and technically.

    We’ve had this discussion before, and you obviously didn’t take anything away from it last time: I doubt very much that you could find me an example of a credentialed doctor that was refused immigration status because of a “restriction on immigration”. Trump’s second term has been an exercise in insanity, so I’m not going to say it’s impossible, but I still don’t think it’s likely to have happened. And that’s because this is a spectrum, with the very obvious need for educated, highly skilled professionals like doctors on one end, and a less obvious need for manual labor on the other. These things are not the same. And frankly… If there was less illegal immigration and that actually led to an actual deficit of farm labor, that would be a great justification for an increase to legal immigration.

    Watcher:

    I honestly can’t number the amount of times people have answered this, but you continue to ask it. I assume because you want to posture as open minded and reasonable while we mad lefties shriek and yell inchoherently at you, the innocent conservative honestly seeking a conversation that we are physiologically incapable of giving you due to our cultural marxist brainwashing.

    I honestly don’t know if this was at me because you made a mistake while quoting. I assume it was at me though, because it’s been a while since Ron responded to anything.

    I’m working from vibes here, not knowing who you’re talking about or what question they asked… But if someone has asked a question a number of times, and you have the impression that they’re asking it because it makes the questioner seem reasonable against the foil of the person being questioned, I think that’s probably an indication that the question hasn’t been answered, with the added undertone that it might not be being answered because the answer to it might not be great for your position. Have you considered answering the question as opposed to attacking the questioner?

  33. Ampersand says:

    I wrote:

    those districts are just a tool to make sure that in certain circumstances, voters in protected classes have an equal opportunity to elect representatives of their choice.

    Ron replied:

    But that’s my point. That last sentence says that Section 2 does not provide such a tool.

    You’re mistaken. The last sentence says “that nothing in this section establishes a right to have members of a protected class elected in numbers equal to their proportion in the population.”

    Having a majority-minority district does not establish “a right to have members of a protected class elected in numbers equal to their proportion in the population”; therefore nothing in that last sentence forbids majority-minority districts (Or other ways to avoid the problem of voting dilution).

    Also, remember that Section 2 also says:

    A violation of subsection (a) is established if, based on the totality of circumstances, it is shown that the political processes leading to nomination or election in the State or political subdivision are not equally open to participation by members of a class of citizens protected by subsection (a) in that its members have less opportunity than other members of the electorate to participate in the political process and to elect representatives of their choice.

    So this isn’t only about citizens as individuals; it’s about rights of a “class of citizens.” So no class of citizens has a right to have members of their protected class elected in proportion to their numbers; but a class of citizens does have the right to equal “opportunity… to elect representatives of their choice.”

    But they are talking about barriers being applied to individual members of those protected classes; that there are no racist mechanisms setting different nomination requirements for people of different races or ethnicities, preventing them from gathering signatures on nomination forms, refusing to accept the forms, refusing to put their names on the ballot, etc.

    Congress explicitly intended Section 2 to cover both barriers to individual members of protected classes, and to vote-dilution cases (which apply to groups, not individuals).

    The Senate Report on Section 2’s meaning as amended in 1982 addresses this explicitly. This is the Senate Judiciary Committee explaining the intent behind the 1982 amendments: “This section without question is aimed at discrimination which takes the form of dilution, as well as outright denial of the right to register or to vote.” (Quoted in Badillo v City of Stockton.)

    If you want to change what the law means, Ron, the proper remedy is to get the law changed by Congress, not to have the Supreme Court act as a super-legislature and contradict Congress’s explicitly stated intent in the 1982 amendments.

    That last sentence means that the law does not mean that State governments are required to create majority-minority districts in an attempt to ensure that minorities are actually elected.

    No, but federal courts can, under certain circumstances, require states to create majority-minority districts as a remedy for unlawful racial vote dilution.

    Yes, the final sentence of Section 2 forbids states from creating minority-majority districts in order to get people of a certain race proportionately elected, but that’s NOT what minority-majority districts do.

  34. Ampersand says:

    Corso:

    1) Majority-minority districts can – and sometimes they have! – benefited Republicans, by making all the districts surrounding the minority-majority district better election environments Republicans. See this study, for instance: “…”of the nine seats taken by the Republicans in 1992, four were due to the creation of majority black districts.”

    2) You’re wrong that the VRA is only about individual rights. It’s about BOTH individual rights and the group right to not have your racial group targeted for vote dilution. As I just pointed out to Ron, the Senate Report on Section 2’s meaning as amended in 1982 addresses this explicitly: “This section without question is aimed at discrimination which takes the form of dilution, as well as outright denial of the right to register or to vote.”

    The “as well as” is important, because it indicates that Congress explicitly meant the VRA to address these two things, not just one of them.

  35. Corso says:

    So this isn’t only about citizens as individuals; it’s about rights of a “class of citizens.” So no class of citizens has a right to have members of their protected class elected in proportion to their numbers; but a class of citizens does have the right to equal “opportunity… to elect representatives of their choice.”

    Not the way you think they do.

    On the idea that “a class” of citizens can have a right… Technically, sure. But ultimately the class is still made up of individuals, the individuals still have to have the right, and the class has to be uniformly disenfranchised of that right. You can’t have a class where some member’s interests are at odds with others. This is perfectly understood in basically every other facet of class law.

    Although African Americans tend to vote very strongly Democrat, they don’t universally vote Democrat. You can’t enfranchise the class of “African Americans” by disenfranchising the African American Republicans inside of it, and once you get past the idea that “African Americans” can act like a class here, “African American Democrats” are not a protected class (although they could be considered a class). The reason why things like poll taxes or competency tests had actionable classes was that even though some members of the class might be able to pay the tax or pass the test, no one actually had an interest in paying the tax or taking the test.

    What’s happened here is that over time, lawmakers have tortured the original VRA to do things it wasn’t originally intended to do with legally awkward language. Legal scholars get to try to disentangle that and figure out how it interacts with reality.

    We get to do a secondary exercise… We can try to have the legal conversation, but I’m kind of interested in the moral one.

    Regardless of whether the law allows (or even requires) it, is anyone going to try to justify the practice of racially segregating people in an attempt to maximize their voting efficiency?

  36. dragon_snap says:

    Corso, let’s look at what the legislation says in Canada (where I live, and iirc, you do as well):

    Electoral Boundaries Readjustment Act, section 15.1 states, in part:

    (b) the commission shall consider the following in determining reasonable electoral district boundaries:

    (i) the community of interest or community of identity in or the historical pattern of an electoral district in the province, and

    and Section 15.2 states in part:

    The commission may depart from the application of the rule set out in paragraph (1)(a) in any case where the commission considers it necessary or desirable to depart therefrom

    (a) in order to respect the community of interest or community of identity in or the historical pattern of an electoral district in the province, or

    (The other parts of 15.1 and 15.2 set out that the districts should be of approximately the same population of people, that they should be “a manageable geographic size for districts in sparsely populated, rural or northern regions of the province,” and by how much can the strictly equal distribution of population be exceeded in order to meet the community of interest and manageable geographic size requirements (+/- 25%).

    Here is a link to the legislation in full: https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/E-3/page-1.html

    Segregating people separates them artificially. If you have a small city, it makes sense to put that whole small city in one riding (electoral district), rather than draw a line partway through. The city is a community of interest, and it makes more sense to share a single representative in the House of Commons, such that all persons, community groups, and businesses in the city have the same MP as their liaison. The city will receive more effective representative representation that way.

    Unless one is doing away with geographic representation entirely and moving to a full Proportional Representation system, it makes the most sense to try to have electoral boundaries match those of communities of interest.

  37. Corso says:

    @dragon_snap

    America is different from Canada. Americans tend to decide that they can’t have nice things because they’re politically advantageous to one side, or racism, or something. Things we (and most democratic nations) take for granted, like voter ID, are incredibly politically fraught in America.

    That material difference here is that up here, I don’t think that people associate the electoral boundary commission with gerrymandering. Sure, there have been times where boundaries have been redrawn and that’s upset local candidates because their seats are less safe, but I don’t think people attribute that to the partisan nature of the commission. I guess it might depend where you are, but if those concerns are out there, I haven’t heard them. I mean… Part of why Poilievre lost his seat is that his district changed and a large Liberal voting neighborhood was added to it… But no one really saw his loss as anything other than a condemnation of his ground game and local popularity.

    Back to the gerrymandering… In order to create some of these “enfranchisement” voting districts, lawmakers cobbled together some really tortured district maps. Look at the maps from Virginia… They took a map that was Gerrymandered, but at least had the benefit of the districts looking compact and geographically sane to looking like a giant pile of spaghetti because there isn’t a fig leaf large enough to cover how geographically untenable these districts are. None of this would be happening here.

  38. Ampersand says:

    What’s happened here is that over time, lawmakers have tortured the original VRA to do things it wasn’t originally intended to do with legally awkward language.

    Is “lawmakers” in this sentence referring to Congress in 1982, or something else?

    Edited to add: Or did you mean state legislatures?

    Or both? Or something else entirely?

    I’m not being sarcastic, I’m honestly unsure of what you meant.

  39. Corso says:

    Is “lawmakers” in this sentence referring to Congress in 1982, or something else?

    Edited to add: Or did you mean state legislatures?

    Or both? Or something else entirely?

    Unsarcastically: Yes.

    My reading on this is that after the VRA was passed in 1965 it was mostly used by the courts as a reinforcement of the 15th amendment, and mostly applied to cases where the southern states were interfering with the rights of African Americans to vote. Then it was amended in 1970, 1975, 1982, 1992, and 2006. And those are the legislative amendments, the court has weighed in dozens of times, the most pertinent was probably in 2013 when they found portions of section 5 preclearance to be unconstitutional. The ’82 amendment probably has the most favorable language for your argument, but the subsection 2(a) argument you mentioned earlier was part of the ’92 amendment. And then you’re right, there are the ways the VRA interacts with state legislation, and their own courts’ additions. It’s a mess, as many things that are contentious and drawn out are, dozens of hands with very different intentions over decades and generations all had their say.

    I’m going to try to steelman your argument:

    “The ’82 amendments clarified the original law, and the people considering the law knew what they were doing. A senate judicial committee at the time said, in part:

    [R]egistration is only the first hurdle to full effective participation in the political process…. [A] broad array of dilution schemes were employed to cancel the impact of the new black vote. Elective posts were made appointive; election boundaries were gerrymandered; majority runoffs were instituted to prevent victories under a prior plurality system; at-large elections were substituted for election by single-member districts, or combined with other sophisticated rules to prevent an effective minority vote. The ingenuity of such schemes seems endless…. Congress anticipated this response. The preclearance provisions of Section 5 were designed to halt such efforts.

    So not only did they think that African Americans could be a class, they explicitly considered gerrymandering as a vector for actionable behavior under the act. They meant to protect against that, and even if the enforcement mechanism was later dismantled by the courts, the practice up until very recently when a violation was found was to require new maps with explicit racially concentrated districts, and I see no reason to change that.”

    Let me know if I missed something.

    There are two responses to that:

    The first is that I don’t think anyone believes that the gerrymandering done in 2026 is racist in intention so much as it’s partisan and because of voting history that happens to have racial implications. Republicans seem more than willing to vote for African American Republicans. This is a problem for you because it interrupts the creation of the class. Because the gerrymandering isn’t racist in design or intention, African Americans as a race aren’t actually being disenfranchised, African American Democrats are.

    Second is that even if you believe otherwise, that the racial implication is enough to invoke the act, and that you can create a class where the interest of the people in the class are divergent… Section 2 says:

    “A violation of subsection (a) is established if, based on the totality of circumstances, it is shown that the political processes leading to nomination or election in the State or political subdivision are not equally open to participation by members of a class of citizens protected by subsection (a) in that its members have less opportunity than other members of the electorate to participate in the political process and to elect representatives of their choice.”

    Even if you want to argue that the partisan gerrymandering is contrary to the act, there is no consideration of reverse-discrimination as a solution. There is no language under the act that gives the minorities of the class more rights than the population at large. There is no language that supports the creation of districts that are created along explicitly racial lines in order to maximize the voting power of that class.

    Even if you believe that the gerrymandered maps are contrary to the voting rights act, and even if you believe that the class exists, the most favorable reading of the act towards your position would require a map that would roughly represent the proportional voting intention of the state, not a re-gerrymandered map that maximized the voting efficiency of the class. Because no one has the right to a maximally efficient vote.

  40. nobody.really says:

    It’s goofy to say that America’s biggest problem is polarization. The biggest problem is aging. That’s why you won’t hear “happy birthday” from me. (Unless you have some audio thing read this comment to you.)

  41. Ampersand says:

    I can’t believe nobody wished me a happy birthday today!

  42. Jacqueline Squid Onassis says:

    I most certainly did! Just not here.

  43. Ampersand says:

    Yes, but you’re somebody.

  44. beth says:

    Nobody lived 3200 years ago in Greece, so it might be hard for him to wish you a happy birthday.

  45. Ampersand says:

    LOL

    You don’t have to make excuses for Nobody, Beth!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *