There’s a lot to disagree with in Paul Krugman’s recent anti-fat column, but I was particularly annoyed by his opening:
The obvious model for those hoping to reverse the fattening of America is the campaign against smoking. Before the surgeon general officially condemned smoking in 1964, rising cigarette consumption seemed an unstoppable trend; since then, consumption per capita has fallen more than 50 percent.
But it may be hard to match that success when it comes to obesity. I’m not talking about the inherent difficulty of the task – getting people to consume fewer calories and/or exercise more may be harder than getting people to stop smoking, but we won’t know until we try.
So it’s Krugman’s view that we haven’t tried yet?
Holy shit!
I mean, the Feds have been speaking out against America’s expanding waistbands, in increasing tones of panic, for decades. Even as Americans get fatter and fatter and live longer and longer, each successive surgeon general has task forced and press released and new programmed and blue-ribbon scientific committeed against the growing fat menace.
And Krugman thinks they haven’t even started yet. I guess that’s better than admitting that yelling and nagging and guilting and kvetching and scolding and sneering and moralizing and chiding and the-sad-fact-is-ing and reproaching at fat people doesn’t actually turn fat people thin.
And the federal government could (and probably will) try it for another few generations, and you know what? It still won’t turn fat people thin. And we’ll keep on getting fatter. And living longer.
Krugman concludes “that the history of government interventions on behalf of public health, from the construction of sewer systems to the campaign against smoking, is one of consistent, life-enhancing success.” That’s only true, of course, if you ignore decades of failed government interventions to make Americans thinner.
P.S. There’s also some anti-corporate rhetoric in Krugman’s article, which I generally agree with. But why – apart from anti-fat ideology – is only the fast food industry criticized? Krugman not only fails to criticize the huge diet and medical corporations which put their weight behind the anti-fat campaign, he mindlessly repeats their party line.
I'm surprised the Tin Man, Scarecrow, and Cowardly Lion aren't getting arrested seeing as they are not U.S. citizens. I…